Silver Dollar questions

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Jexnell

Bronze Tier VIP
MFK Member
Jul 17, 2017
5,835
12,540
493
PNW
So I am thinking of moving my Roseline sharks to my JD tank from my Oscar tank. Taking the Giant Danios back to the LFS, and getting Silver Dollar's for the Oscar tank. Are they schoolers and need a min number to feel safe? What would be a good breed to go with an Oscar?
 
For regular silverdollars (metynnis argenteus), spotted silverdollars (metynnis lippincottianus), tiger striped dollars (metynnis fasciatus) you can do 6 or so.
Red hooks and black bars, 3-4 is a good number because they do grow a bit bigger. Red hooks usually get up to 8-10'' (12'' is possible, but rare), wide bar silverdollars anywhere from 10-14'', and thin bars stay like metynnis size 6-9''.
I think you will love silver dollars, like me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jexnell
For regular silverdollars (metynnis argenteus), spotted silverdollars (metynnis lippincottianus), tiger striped dollars (metynnis fasciatus) you can do 6 or so.
Red hooks and black bars, 3-4 is a good number because they do grow a bit bigger. Red hooks usually get up to 8-10'' (12'' is possible, but rare), wide bar silverdollars anywhere from 10-14'', and thin bars stay like metynnis size 6-9''.
I think you will love silver dollars, like me.

Thanks for this info just what I was looking for. They are going into a 55gal with a baby oscar 6 inchish range. I just redid her aquascape and think the silver dollers and her would look great swimming around the driftwood. The Wet Spot has redhooks think ill get 3 we will see for sure when I get over there.
20170922_162623.jpg
 
Thanks for this info just what I was looking for. They are going into a 55gal with a baby oscar 6 inchish range. I just redid her aquascape and think the silver dollers and her would look great swimming around the driftwood. The Wet Spot has redhooks think ill get 3 we will see for sure when I get over there.
View attachment 1276011





Tbh a 55 gallon is problematic for even spotted SD's when spooked they will swim right into aquarium glass. I have seen small ones you may consider to growout until you upgrade. I have spotted SD's in my 180 gallon and they are extremely fast but aquarium is long enough to prevent injurys.
 
Ok ill just wait till the upgrade then to get them. Maybe get more sharks in the meantime. Thanks all for the information.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
I really do not understand why people attempt to keep any sort of silver dollars in 55 gallon tanks. It's just a bad idea full stop.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AquaAlex1993
MonsterFishKeepers.com