Well - Zoodiver - I had actually heard that about Bonnetheads. And that the keeper needs to be a professional at shark keeping - to take care of bonnetheads .
As for Atlantic sharpnose Sharks - Living in N.C.(as I do) I seen dozens of these shark caught be fishermen both from piers & the shore during the simmer months. These are often called "sand" sharks. And I've never seen any sharpnose above 40 inches in length. I've heard of the reaching up to 4 ft in length - but the atlantic species never gets close to the 6 ft in length as you've stated. All of the biological sources(written by either marine biologists or shark experts), I've ever read on the Atlantic Sharpnose - state that the maximum length for this species of sharpnose only grows to be about 3.6 to 4 ft in length. And the only sharpnose species the actually comes close to 6ft in length is the Pacific Sharpnose or Milk Shark.
The fact is there are at least 5 different species of sharpnose sharks - The Atlantic, the Caribbean, The Brazilian, the Pacific(Milk), & the Australian. The Pacific is the largest(nearly 6 ft long), the Brazilian is the smallest (about 2.5 ft long), with the other 3 species, all about 3-4ft in length.
I know that The Atlantic Sharpnose prefer to living in schools, & perfer very warm water(about 79F or hotter).
Also for the record - my estimates for gallons size of each species is based on a single shark. So if someone were to keep 4 sharpnoses together - your tank would need to be at least 8,400 gallons(18 ft diameter x 4-4.5ft deep). Also I would recommend re-enforcing the walls with fiberglass or heavy plastic, plus an additional 2 ft plex-glass wall(above the normal wall) aroung the tank(to prevent jumping out).
Still I would recommend the Atlantic Sharpnose over the Blacktip Reef - any day for some one who's seriously considering a requiem shark - due to it's(sharpnose) temperment
As for Blacktip Reef Sharks - these guys are commonly seen in the trade - and alot of miss information about them. They will regularly reach 5-6ft in length, can get up to 6.5ft long. And yes, they are powerful swimmers. So like the sharpnose they really need a reenforced tank(as adults).
Of course some people actually confuse the Blacktip Reef(Indo-Pacific species) with the Blacktip(Atlantic species). These are by no means the same sharks. The Atlantic species is larger (averages 6.5ft , maxs out at about 8ft), and has a more aggressive personality.
Truth is the Atlantic Blacktip should only be kept by public aquariums or shark experts.