Smallest piranha?

[guppy]

I was lloking through the listings in www.fishbase.org., a normally reliable source, and found some errors (like the isaline's cachorro being only 4" long when the last one I had was 14") so here are the five smallest serrasalmus species that they have listed, I know a couple are wrong so I will list their reported size and also the largest that I have found listed from reputable sites.
If you have first hand knowledge of larger ones please chime in with corrections.
S. sanchesi 4 1/2", (8")
S. nalseni 5", (7")
S. irritans 5 1/2", (6")
S. medinai 6", (8")
S. hastatus 6 1/4", (6 1/2")

 

[gman]

How can this be guppy doesnt know?

 

[JD7.62]

Damnit gman now you have that damn song "scotty doesnt know" stuck in my head from Euro Trip!

As far as the list the only one I have personal experience is, as I stated in another thread, the S. Sanchezi who depending on the size imported can get 6"+. Mine was no less then 5" though I did not notice any more growth in the few months I had him.

What is an S. nalseni? I have never even heard of one before.

 

[guppy]

Damnit gman now you have that damn song "scotty doesnt know" stuck in my head from Euro Trip!

As far as the list the only one I have personal experience is, as I stated in another thread, the S. Sanchezi who depending on the size imported can get 6"+. Mine was no less then 5" though I did not notice any more growth in the few months I had him.

What is an S. nalseni? I have never even heard of one before.

this one http://www.opefe.com/nalseni.html

 

[guppy]

How can this be guppy doesnt know?

I am a victim of conflicting data. heheh.

 

[toxicfish]

How can this be guppy doesnt know?

lol..... thats what I thought as soon as I seen this thread.


I bet guppy ends up answering his own thread.

 

[Zbiljc]

Which is the smallest piranha at Pygocentrus?