Solo Piranha for a community tank?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
OP still waiting for you to show those successful community tanks that you so called worked with keeping piranhas in a community tank please.
 
Of course, in case I'm lying. Duh.

Thing is, I don't have a habit of archiving every article I've ever read, so you'll just have to take my word for it.

A quick search on youtube however turns up several videos of seemingly peaceful community tanks, I won't bother linking. Also come to think of it one of the articles I read previously were of particular interest, I'll see if I can't unearth it somehow.

Anyways, I know the general understanding among fish keepers is that piranhas should always be kept in species only tanks, but as I understand it very few of the people repeating that have actually kept piranhas in community tanks. So I guess that's why I started a thread here, to see if any of you have actual firsthand (or credible secondhand) experience.

Just for the record, I'm not planning on doing this any time soon, it's a thought experiment, and it will probably remain so for a while yet.
 
The thread is old titled What is the sillyest thing you did as a fishkeeper but not absolutely sure. Well anyway I actually put a baby Redbelly around the 2 inches in my mother's 30 gallon community tank and it wasted no time attacking the inhabitants. My mother was not happy.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com