Someone please answer my questions :)

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Tristan foreman

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Dec 2, 2016
6
2
3
35
I have two Jaguars cichlids . Can someone tell me if they are a pair , female or male & . The big one picks up rocks and put them to a side of the tank. They've been aggressive to other fish but not to each other .
Pls help

image.jpeg

image.jpeg

image.jpeg

image.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frank Castle
second and third picture is definitely a male.
i guess its safe to assume the other is female if they're hanging out. but ill let someone else verify that.
 
pretty sure it's a pair, if it wasn't they'd have killed each other, probably cuz ehh ehh is right, the big one is definitely a male

What size tank?
 
Tank is a 55 gallon
Yikes! Are you planning on a tank upgrade anytime soon? Not trying to slam you, but a 55 is way too small for the fish you have. A male jag can get 16"+ and a 55 is only 12" wide.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GamerChick5567
In your first pic the one on the left looks female, the darker bars tend to be a female trait, but could also be traits of a less dominant male.
And the right looks to be alpha male, less barring, and maybe a steeper profile.
But clear close ups would help in a more accurate gender ID, where the profiles were much more obvious, differences are often subtle so you need to show photos that present those differences.
Here are examples
a pair of N tetracanthus, note the males steep profile, and females torpedo shape

P motaguense, even though the male in the back is out of focus, his profile obviously contrasts with the female

and because managuense gender differences are often more subtle, this is the reason your photos need to be more concise, obvious, and closer.
And I agree with robham777, a pair of managuense in a small tank like 55 is asking for a dead female
 
  • Like
Reactions: robham777
In your first pic the one on the left looks female, the darker bars tend to be a female trait, but could also be traits of a less dominant male.
And the right looks to be alpha male, less barring, and maybe a steeper profile.
But clear close ups would help in a more accurate gender ID, where the profiles were much more obvious, differences are often subtle so you need to show photos that present those differences.
Here are examples
a pair of N tetracanthus, note the males steep profile, and females torpedo shape.
P motaguense, even though the male in the back is out of focus, his profile obviously contrasts with the female
and because managuense gender differences are often more subtle, this is the reason your photos need to be more concise, obvious, and closer.
And I agree with robham777, a pair of managuense in a small tank like 55 is asking for a dead female
Im upgrading them to a 100 gallon today
Yikes! Are you planning on a tank upgrade anytime soon? Not trying to slam you, but a 55 is way too small for the fish you have. A male jag can get 16"+ and a 55 is only 12" wide.
im upgrade them to a 100 today
 
Are they going to try and kill each other after the spawn
100g is still tight quarters for a breeding pair of Jags. I would encourage you to have a means of dividing the tank if they do spawn. Even if everything seems to be going well, the situation can turn on a dime. This would be true for a larger tank as well. Assuming you have a pair.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kewpiefishypewpie
MonsterFishKeepers.com