Sponge filter seems like it's doing nothing?

[jstehman]

I have a 120gph powerhead on a hydro 4 (I think 4)

It collects LOTS of junk every week in my 125.

Is the sponge going to be the only filtration in the tank?

Sent from my SCH-I535 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App

 

[TheBroc]

so even tho they say max tank size 50 gallons its ok?

 

[TheBroc]

no scroll up. I have TWO 405 canisters (rated at 100 gallons each) on my 135 g. is that enough? I have large messy fish.

 

[rmkblades]

Forget the sponge...you already have 2 405s. Just add more flow so their is no debris on the tank bottom. I have this exact one and the 3200gph one on opposite sides of my 110g and the fish love it. I'm sure it reminds them of home, lol

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Circulation...eef-Powerhead-Suction-Cup-Mount-/251070391913

 

[jstehman]

If youre getting enough biofiltration I would say the canisters are enough. Still need to change water too

I mai nly use the sponge as a polisher and my canisters as mechanical. But im also fully planted.

I will always use a sponge in my tanks

Sent from my SCH-I535 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App

 

[thoth666]

If youre getting enough biofiltration I would say the canisters are enough. Still need to change water too

I mai nly use the sponge as a polisher and my canisters as mechanical. But im also fully planted.

I will always use a sponge in my tanks

Sent from my SCH-I535 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App

Why always use a sponge in your tank? Are you saying your sponge mostly catches fine particulates in the way floss would?

 

[lp85253]

Why always use a sponge in your tank? Are you saying your sponge mostly catches fine particulates in the way floss would?

yes they do.... the are also great backup bio filters that don't need to be cleaned very often(if used with air pump)...so in summary ..if you don't use sponge filters, fine , but don't rip em because they "don't do much",cause that is not correct info(this isn't directed at ANYONE in particular,just a general statement)

 

[jstehman]

I meant that I will always have a sponge in at least one tank. Great biofiltration.. fine particulates... seeding another filter/tank.

Plus its way easier to reach in and grab the sponge to rinse it out as opposed to dragging out a canister which is why I dont run floss in canisters.

You can even go green and use the "squeeze out bucket" to water your plants/garden.

The pros outweigh the cons for me.

Sent from my SCH-I535 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App

 

[jstehman]

Just used one of my sponge filters to set up a QT tank for a new arrival. Gotta love instant cycling

signature
-----------------------------------------------------------

"And if I can't have everything, well then just give me a taste"