spotted gar tankmates?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Personally I would go with 2 spotted just to ensure an ample amount of room for each and minimize the chance for aggression or squabbles between the two. 3 is probably doable and I'd imagine you could get away with it, but the more swimming room for these fish, the better. Also the TSN and the CK are going to grow pretty huge in that tank.
Remember that many other fish do not have the space requirements of gars. Basically, gars (and TSN) cannot use the available tank space all that effectively. Most fish can and will bend and maneuver, whereas the gars are completely stiff in all their movements. Also there is always the chance of adding more large robust fish if you'd like to add some tankmates later on.
Sidenote: If you get the TSN and CK small and grow them out you should have some kind of cave, piping, tubing, or something for them to hide in. Both do not like heavy lighting and are nocturnal, so a diffusion of light or some kind of light-barriers are appropriate for both.
For the CK especially, IMO, they need at least 1 unclaimed space that they can wedge themselves into to hide from light and escape the other species in the tank. Then again the TSN might decide that it likes the space for the CK, hence my suggestion for a few hiding spots. A couple large chunks of wood towards the opposite ends of the tank would work well.
Once they get larger its a different story.
 
ok. im not going to do a TSN in this tank, im going to grow out some of them in another tank for my pond though, a tigrinus only gets to about 2 foot, or in short, the zebra shovelnose. ill try to find some hiding spots for the CK and the tig. thanks

nitro
 
yeah, itll be

1 African Arowana (always wanted to try one)
2 Spotted Gar
1 Clown knifefish
1 tigrinus cat
 
aggressor09;2248565; said:
Personally I would go with 2 spotted just to ensure an ample amount of room for each and minimize the chance for aggression or squabbles between the two. 3 is probably doable and I'd imagine you could get away with it, but the more swimming room for these fish, the better. Also the TSN and the CK are going to grow pretty huge in that tank.
Remember that many other fish do not have the space requirements of gars. Basically, gars (and TSN) cannot use the available tank space all that effectively. Most fish can and will bend and maneuver, whereas the gars are completely stiff in all their movements. Also there is always the chance of adding more large robust fish if you'd like to add some tankmates later on.
Sidenote: If you get the TSN and CK small and grow them out you should have some kind of cave, piping, tubing, or something for them to hide in. Both do not like heavy lighting and are nocturnal, so a diffusion of light or some kind of light-barriers are appropriate for both.
For the CK especially, IMO, they need at least 1 unclaimed space that they can wedge themselves into to hide from light and escape the other species in the tank. Then again the TSN might decide that it likes the space for the CK, hence my suggestion for a few hiding spots. A couple large chunks of wood towards the opposite ends of the tank would work well.
Once they get larger its a different story.


this is not correct as they are not completely stiff in all their movements. gars may be more rigid than a lot of fishes, but they are not THAT rigid. they are actually surprisingly flexible, and the primary inflexible part of the whole fish is the head, not the entire body. observe gars in the wild and you can see this (or netting them up, etc etc).

also, a 360g tank with one larger sp of catfish is just fine for 4 spotted (likely Florida) gars as they will likely not outgrow that space in captivity over the course of their lives. this is figuring on raising up YOY (young of the year) individuals in the aquarium. 4 wild-caught adults would likely need more space.

that being said, and given the recent posts, it sounds like the setup should be in decent shape. good luck--
--solomon
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com