Substrate Decisions

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

ZeroOne

Candiru
MFK Member
Sep 26, 2010
105
0
46
Canada
Ok, some of you have seen my white silica sand grow out tank for my bichir and a few other fishies. They are all fine but unfortunately the coloured red silica I added isn't slowing down my ornates bleaching. He's starting to really bleach out in colour which is not what I wanted and was hoping would happen at a slower rate. He's comfortable and doing fine (they all are) and now I'm trying to decide what to replace it with. I want to keep those nice bright colours as long as I can.

Black tahitian moon sand: been told can be expensive, but won't leech things into the water. downside, I'm told it's really light and can be sucked into the filter.

Chinese garnet sand: Can get easily, colour is a dark red. Inert, but not really sure if it will be ok with my fish. Also much heavier so won't get sucked into the filter.

Fish in there are african brown knife, 1x sen, 1x ornate, african butterfly, and 1x krib. They are all still very small.

Curious on peoples opinions, haven't really used sand other than white silica so not sure. Also not sure if any other sands should be used instead, was really hoping for a black to help keep the ornates colour though. And I've heared very mixed things about pool filter sand so not sure about that.
 
I have the Black Tahitian Sand. It's a fine grade of sand but, as long as you don't have your filter intake a couple of inches from the bottom, it won't get sucked up.
 
I can get the moon sand from the LFS near me 20lbs for $24. I called a few aggregate companies near me about the coloured quartz and they said they have never heard of the product. One guy said "I keep fish and I don't know what your talking about, doesn't exist. You should do your research on the internet more." So I went to explain to him and he hung up on me. lol
 
Here in Japan, crushed garnet sand is pretty much the "standard" with Polypterus.

I have most of my tanks using this, and looks very nice. Very heavy, which is a good thing.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com