Super green texas.. NOT

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Lil g

Gambusia
MFK Member
Jan 25, 2016
318
16
18
36
Ok so here is an update of my Escondido pearlscale cichlid... I would live to breed these guys but now I'm second guessing if mine I'd even a male... I've asked this before but my fish was still too small..... Here "he" is lol.. Also I just got a Barton cichlid? Does anybody know much about these.?there isn't much info on the internet.

Screenshot_2016-08-14-02-50-14.png

Screenshot_2016-08-14-02-49-09.png
 
Looks identical to mine, it was sold as a cyanoguttatus, not sure if male/female

tmp_6514-IMAG0176-285978757.jpg
 
Looks identical to mine, it was sold as a cyanoguttatus, not sure if male/female

View attachment 1197934
yes I know that it's really not a Texas cichlid mine was sold as an Escondido pearlscale cichlid but everyone always says they are Texas cichlids which obviously is not the case.. You can tell by the pearling.. Texas cichlids are small and pearlscales are well pearls lol.
 
OP your's looks like a female Herichthys carpintus and it may be a "location Escondido".
Although there is really no way to know if the Escondido location was simply a selling point or if your seller was legit. All those "super Green titles and stuff are just hyperbole.
The reason I say female, is because its profile is torpedo shaped, and I think I see a dark area in the dorsal, but since you took the shot with the dorsal when it was folded down, its hard to tell.
Below is a female Herichthys carpintus location "chairel" the dorsal is slightly up, so you can see the dark area better

now a male, note the steeper profile, and lack of dark color in the dorsal

The fin trailers on yours are very male, but are not always a true indicator, so try to get a very more clear photo with the dorsal fin erect.
And sometimes, if there is a more dominant cichlid in the same tank (doesn't need to be the same species) or if a dominant female is present, a male will feign female colors.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Frank Castle
I've just noticed the part in your post about Nosferatu bartoni.
I have kept them and they have spawned for me, and are a great cichlid to keep, given enough room.
They are fairly aggressive, from Mexico, and do well at normal aquarium temps. Sometimes in their natural area water temp gets quite cool (mid 60sF), and often found with Herichthys carpintus.
below a male

now a female

although a small cichlid, I kept my pair in a 100 gal tank, when I gave the pair to a friend he put them in a 55 gal, and the female was immediately killed.
they both make excellent parents, tending the fry for an extended period

in my 100, six foot gal, they spawned on one end of the tank, while a pair of African Lepidiolamprologus spawned on the other side, and at times the fry would commingle.
Probably wouldn't happen that way in a smaller tank
 
I've just noticed the part in your post about Nosferatu bartoni.
I have kept them and they have spawned for me, and are a great cichlid to keep, given enough room.
They are fairly aggressive, from Mexico, and do well at normal aquarium temps. Sometimes in their natural area water temp gets quite cool (mid 60sF), and often found with Herichthys carpintus.
below a male

now a female

although a small cichlid, I kept my pair in a 100 gal tank, when I gave the pair to a friend he put them in a 55 gal, and the female was immediately killed.
they both make excellent parents, tending the fry for an extended period

in my 100, six foot gal, they spawned on one end of the tank, while a pair of African Lepidiolamprologus spawned on the other side, and at times the fry would commingle.
Probably wouldn't happen that way in a smaller tank
wow thanks! They look so awsome I'm do happy I made the split decision to pick one up when I saw them. Granted I knew nothing about them lol... Too bad I only got one. How come there is so little information about these guys?
 
OP your's looks like a female Herichthys carpintus and it may be a "location Escondido".
Although there is really no way to know if the Escondido location was simply a selling point or if your seller was legit. All those "super Green titles and stuff are just hyperbole.
The reason I say female, is because its profile is torpedo shaped, and I think I see a dark area in the dorsal, but since you took the shot with the dorsal when it was folded down, its hard to tell.
Below is a female Herichthys carpintus location "chairel" the dorsal is slightly up, so you can see the dark area better

now a male, note the steeper profile, and lack of dark color in the dorsal

The fin trailers on yours are very male, but are not always a true indicator, so try to get a very more clear photo with the dorsal fin erect.
And sometimes, if there is a more dominant cichlid in the same tank (doesn't need to be the same species) or if a dominant female is present, a male will feign female colors.
 
OP your's looks like a female Herichthys carpintus and it may be a "location Escondido".
Although there is really no way to know if the Escondido location was simply a selling point or if your seller was legit. All those "super Green titles and stuff are just hyperbole.
The reason I say female, is because its profile is torpedo shaped, and I think I see a dark area in the dorsal, but since you took the shot with the dorsal when it was folded down, its hard to tell.
Below is a female Herichthys carpintus location "chairel" the dorsal is slightly up, so you can see the dark area better

now a male, note the steeper profile, and lack of dark color in the dorsal

The fin trailers on yours are very male, but are not always a true indicator, so try to get a very more clear photo with the dorsal fin erect.
And sometimes, if there is a more dominant cichlid in the same tank (doesn't need to be the same species) or if a dominant female is present, a male will feign female colors.

20160619_184818.jpg

20160619_184836.jpg
 
There is plenty of info about them, places like The Cichlid Room Companion, the American Cichlid Association, or Cichlid News magazine are all great resources. They are not simply your LFS bread and butter species, because even small, they are aggressive and can decimate a community tank, if not enough space is provided.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lil g
Is that
There is plenty of info about them, places like The Cichlid Room Companion, the American Cichlid Association, or Cichlid News magazine are all great resources. They are not simply your LFS bread and butter species, because even small, they are aggressive and can decimate a community tank, if not enough space is provided.
Is that picture better of the dorsal fin...
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com