As mentioned before, if you have the money, and space go for the 75. If not maintain the water changes like you mentioned before, and save up. I have heard all kinds of people keeping the O's in all kinds of environments ex: tank foot prints and dimensions. Just be reasonable and consider that your O can and probably will top out at the 13-15in mark, and again think about what would be best for him. In addition someone mentioned go as large as you can. I would rather save several months and buy the 75, rather than purchase the 50 because that was what I could afford at the time, then realize down the road how he dwarfs the tank. Good luck in what you decide. Dont forget his tank mates potential size either.