tanks falling through floors?!

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

FISHSTICKS89

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Jul 15, 2012
301
3
0
vancity
is this even possible. at what size could tanks be sagging and damaging to a house/apartment.

basements are ideal but what if not an option.
Sent from my SGH-T959P using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
Well 1st off jus gonna throw this out there is... Through... Not threw... Lol but it depends on the buil of the house there is a thread somewhere on here where a guy put steel I beems through a load bearing wall in his house... The load bearimg wall is met to deel with that kind of pressure so instead of the tank being on the floor essentiall all its weight was on the wall.... Do some searching you will find it... Prolly like 300 replys or somethin to read through tho.... It was a progression thread... Nice tank in the end...

Sent from my SPH-D710 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
is this even possible. at what size could tanks be sagging and damaging to a house/apartment.

basements are ideal but what if not an option.
Sent from my SGH-T959P using MonsterAquariaNetwork App

A number of factors could make this possible. How well the house is built, was the tank placed across the floor studs, or the other way (possibly covering only 1-2 studs?, is the tank near a supporting wall, or right in the middle of the room?

Just talking about this makes me think of the time I renovated my parents den. I ripped off the dry wall to find a supporting wall where some of the studs weren't even contacting the ground. Its like they cut them to short and just said "oh well". The house was built in the early 60's as a model home. Its like they fired it together in a hurry without much care, so they could quickly show it off. Even some of the floor studs were higher then others and not evenly spaced. I've worked in renovation/demolition for a few years, and some of the stuff I've seen would make Mike Holmes drop to his knees weeping. :ROFL:

So yes, I could see a bigger tank falling through the floor, under the right circumstances. As far as the size goes, I don't think I'd put anything bigger then a 125g on an upper floor, although I know people do. Even a 125g with water, sand, rocks, the stand itself, your looking at 1500lbs+. A little scary in my opinion.

If your asking this question because your planning on doing it, and are questioning whether the floor can take it, I'd suggest not doing it. Could be one hell of a repair bill. :thumbsdow

Big tanks should go in basements imo.
 
I'd have to imagine that the floor would bow enough to cause pressure points in the glass and pop the tank before it actually fell through the floor. Unless you were somehow miraculously able to miss every joist with a big tank. I suppose it is possible with a very tall tank that is less than 16" wide, and your floor is rotted.


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
Well 1st off jus gonna throw this out there is... Through... Not threw... Lol but it depends on the buil of the house there is a thread somewhere on here where a guy put steel I beems through a load bearing wall in his house... The load bearimg wall is met to deel with that kind of pressure so instead of the tank being on the floor essentiall all its weight was on the wall.... Do some searching you will find it... Prolly like 300 replys or somethin to read through tho.... It was a progression thread... Nice tank in the end...

Sent from my SPH-D710 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App

Not to derail but I love that you corrected him for "threw" then went and spelled "build" with an invisible d lol
 
Well 1st off jus gonna throw this out there is... Through... Not threw... Lol but it depends on the buil of the house there is a thread somewhere on here where a guy put steel I beems through a load bearing wall in his house... The load bearimg wall is met to deel with that kind of pressure so instead of the tank being on the floor essentiall all its weight was on the wall.... Do some searching you will find it... Prolly like 300 replys or somethin to read through tho.... It was a progression thread... Nice tank in the end...

Sent from my SPH-D710 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App

He didn't say 'Threw'...
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com