Try a 2.5 or 3" gulp minnow (I like any of the two tone minnow colors) and rig it on a 1/8oz or lighter plain jighead. Retrieve it with either short hops or a straight reel. With a little practice, it is easily one of the top lures for both size and numbers of trout.
Ok thanks I know there have to be big trout in the stocked pond because they put 500 in and I am sure that not everyone of them were kept. Anyway I was planning on using salmon eggs to try to catch the big boys. Is that a good idea?
It doesn't matter what the bait or fly is really as long its presented the right way to the right fish. I have personally caught more fish and bigger fish on a fly rod than a spin rod.
Depending the conditions of the pond that 12" could have been a big one. Many rainbows only reach the 12" -14" range in less then ideal conditions But they could have stocked it with a strain of rainbows that can grow faster in many conditions. Plus they don't have a very long life-span 3-4 years in small streams idk about the pond you're fishing, and up to 8 years in the great lakes. I live on lake superior and I catch a lot on a spoon I like to try all different sizes, sometimes a big spoon works, sometimes a small one.
Ok well I actually think they are big rainbows though because they stock 500 of them every year and I am certain not all of them get caught. Thanks I'll definitely try salmon eggs