Tetra Whisper Vs. RENA air pumps

[Deaths Sting]

im trying to find a good air pump for my 15 gallon, 24'' X 12'' X 12''

anyone have experiences with either Tetra Whisper or RENA air pumps?

 

[BPags52]

I have a Whisper 20 hooked up to a 4" airstone just to give my 125g a lil' extra aeration. It pushes alot of air and is pretty quiet (not quite silent, but much quieter than an old air pump I had (penn-plax silent-air I think).

No experience with Renas...

 

[Deaths Sting]

I have a Whisper 20 hooked up to a 4" airstone just to give my 125g a lil' extra aeration. It pushes alot of air and is pretty quiet (not quite silent, but much quieter than an old air pump I had (penn-plax silent-air I think).

No experience with Renas...

thanks, anyone else?

 

[Deaths Sting]

 

[uncwnells]

I have the blue whispers that look like some sort of alien robot, they have legs etc. and they are pretty much silent when they arent placed beside something. never owned a rena, but thats because i like the whispers so much.

 

[Full Metal Gundam]

rena's are overrated save some $ and just buy a Whisper.

 

[rdx1555]

My Rena started out pretty noisy for a couple months but has now quieted down. Only reason I bought it was because it was on sale and came with a free air stone. .

 

[Deaths Sting]

whisper it is!

thanks everyone

 

[tcarswell]

I have the blue whispers that look like some sort of alien robot, they have legs etc. and they are pretty much silent when they arent placed beside something. never owned a rena, but thats because i like the whispers so much.

Both have been good to me. I have this model noted above and others the dual outlet model and the single outlet of both rena and whispers

 

[sonycrr]

i have a rena 300 and 100 and these things are loud.