The dangerous shrimp...

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Piscineidiot

Gambusia
MFK Member
Jul 28, 2008
128
0
16
QLD Australia
I posted this up a while back in another category, but after having had a look around, I realised that arowana keepers seem to feed the most 'market shrimp' to their pets. That, and the fact that arowana are extremely expensive and much loved has led me to post this up.

Just thought I'd send out a warning to all those fish keepers who source their foods from seafood markets.

It's often tempting to buy a large, fresh shrimp/prawn to treat our monsters back at home, or the various inverterbrates that many keep in their marine tanks, however, this is much more often than not, a very bad idea.

Shrimp and prawns used for human consumption are almost always treated with a water soluble preservative (the exact name of which escapes me at this point in time). This preservative allows the prawns to be kept for longer in the fridge, and on display without discolouration to the shell and the head itself, meaning that they're appealling for longer. Other chemical additions can also 'improve' the texture of the prawn etc.

All of these are considered toxic unless dissolved in water and 'cooked out'.

Therefore, all of these are TOXIC TO YOUR FISH.

If you want to feed your pets some fresh seafood, you're better off catching it yourself, or buying something other than prawns/shrimp. Either that, or get some fresh squid, or fish flesh (but be careful which types you choose...stay away from deepwater species as they can often have high levels of waxy ester, which isn't immediately poisonous, but might cause digestive upsets; Also, try not to buy something that may have high levels of heavy metals e.g. swordfish, marlin, tuna etc. you won't die, but your fish are much smaller than you are.)

Bait is actually quite a good alternative. Buy a packet of frozen prawns, or squid, or whatever, as these are all snap-frozen. It is actually illegal for those baits to be treated with preservatives (at least in Australia). The snap freezing process should also have eliminated most potentially harmful pathogens for you, though not all.

Anyway, this is just information that I garnered from working in fish markets for many years, and while none of these things will result in immediate fatalities, they can potentially harm your pets, and will almost certainly shorten their lifespans.

So, take care when you buy your pets treats, and may they live long, stay strong and shine bright!

Cheers,

Piscineidiot
 
Really???

I sometimes eat them raw, because I cant afford sushi Q.Q

Well, I eat half, and throw the other half into the tank o...o,,
 
There are no preservatives on non-imported U.S. shrimp. By law it has to have it listed on the package if it does have any kind of preservative which includes extra salt. Shrimp imported into the U.S. is a different story though as the government can't test/regulate it quick enough before it goes on the shelf. By the way are you thinking of MSG? BHT?
 
Knowdafish;2205359; said:
There are no preservatives on non-imported U.S. shrimp. By law it has to have it listed on the package if it does have any kind of preservative which includes extra salt. Shrimp imported into the U.S. is a different story though as the government can't test/regulate it quick enough before it goes on the shelf. By the way are you thinking of MSG? BHT?

Well, that's a comforting thought for the US people. Unfortunately, it's not a requirement here in Australia, though we do have to tell if someone asks. It's not MSG or BHT. The name's pretty long, and it's been a while since I've worked in a fish market now. It's not a flavouring agent, it stops the prawns from discolouration.
 
MSG = monosodium glutamate, BHT = [FONT=verdana, geneva, helvetica]butylated hydroxytoluene

There is also BHA =
[/FONT][FONT=verdana, geneva, helvetica]Butylated hydroxyanisole

You can google "food preservatives" and maybe come up with the one you're thinking of if these are not it.
[/FONT]
 
nice info bro. i thought market shrimp are the safest and healthier for our fish.
 
There is a famous incident at a local crocodile show of crocs dying because of chemicals in raw chicken which was meant for human consumption. When you cook the chicken the preservatives feed to them cook out. The shop I bought my arow from told me this, he said live home grown crickets and live fresh water shrimp is the safest diet, with sticks as well if possible.
 
classic-chassis;2205636; said:
There is a famous incident at a local crocodile show of crocs dying because of chemicals in raw chicken which was meant for human consumption. When you cook the chicken the preservatives feed to them cook out. The shop I bought my arow from told me this, he said live home grown crickets and live fresh water shrimp is the safest diet, with sticks as well if possible.

Lucky for you (and me), live fresh water shrimp is availalbe where we live ^^ i suppose i better stop feeding frozen shrimp to my aros then.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com