to RTC or not to RTC

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
thanks...........how the tank doing ???


wizzin;665359; said:
The public aquarium keeper suggested 5000 gallon minimum for one of these. Also, he mentioned that the 2 they have now were 12" when they got them in 99, and by 2002 they were 36". 2006 they're 4'. They slow down at 36".
 
johnptc;665320; said:
@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@ again its the fish keeper and not the fish that are to blame.......... wizzin did the right thing by getting enough info to make what i believe is the approriate decision.............@@@@@@@@@@@@@@

I am asking myself the same question for the 5000 gallon tank I have and am still undecided..........rtc tsn or none of the above !! ??:confused: :confused: :confused:



Without a doubt but my point is there are few who have these who can fully accomidate them when full grown. There are some, don't get me wrong but a small percentage of the people buying. My point is the price on such a fish should be raised or possibly even a permit required. But that's off topic.


My other point was if you're concerned about a 4ft red tailed cat eating smaller fish then it'd be wise not to get one hoping it won't.
 
maybe the lfs should take responsibility for educating thieir customers !!!!!:ROFL: :ROFL:

rule of thumb for rtc is if it can be forced into its mouth it will probaly get eaten !!!!!!!!!:cry: :cry: :cry: :cry: :cry:



cichlaguapote;665527; said:
Without a doubt but my point is there are few who have these who can fully accomidate them when full grown. There are some, don't get me wrong but a small percentage of the people buying. My point is the price on such a fish should be raised or possibly even a permit required. But that's off topic.


My other point was if you're concerned about a 4ft red tailed cat eating smaller fish then it'd be wise not to get one hoping it won't.
 
johnptc;665544; said:
maybe the lfs should take responsibility for educating thieir customers !!!!!:ROFL: :ROFL:

rule of thumb for rtc is if it can be forced into its mouth it will probaly get eaten !!!!!!!!!:cry: :cry: :cry: :cry: :cry:


Educated or not there are always a majority that think they have a plan for what to do with a 3-4ft or even less rtc when it outgrows its home or eats too much. I see people all the time saying "I scored a RTC at the lfs for $5", or $10.00 or whatever which is great but keeping that fish will cost you way more than $5.00 if you're truely devoted to it.

Educating customers is good but a majority of people buying fish that will eventually need a new home don't need as much educating as pre-thought before telling the store to bag that rtc for them.
 
Sunpoe;662504; said:
If I had the tank space I would definately get an RTC. I would not waste all that tank space for O's, even though they are cool fish, you could easily buy a far smaller tank for them and have the best of both worlds.

:iagree: A pair of Os in a 125 and the RTC in with a bunch of convicts. They will be a natural food source for the RTC after a bit.
 
I agree..........however I think alot of buyers have no clue what it takes to house a 2 foot rtc let alone 4 - 5 foot garabge disposal :) :) :)

cichlaguapote;665552; said:
Educated or not there are always a majority that think they have a plan for what to do with a 3-4ft or even less rtc when it outgrows its home or eats too much. I see people all the time saying "I scored a RTC at the lfs for $5", or $10.00 or whatever which is great but keeping that fish will cost you way more than $5.00 if you're truely devoted to it.

Educating customers is good but a majority of people buying fish that will eventually need a new home don't need as much educating as pre-thought before telling the store to bag that rtc for them.
 
i know i dident 'when i got my rtc i thought it get to maybe a foot or so till i started looking up what he was. At my lfs they dident tell me anthing about him he was about an inch big when i got him
 
I work at an lfs, and I pretty much wont stock them anymore. I've gotten way too many "drop offs" that I have to deal with, before they break my tanks. No thanks. If you can house them though, long term, they are awesome.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com