I liked their early stuff. Then I bought A Perfect Circle when I was in Saudi. That was the only CD I had for the three months I was there. I just don't seem to like Maynard as much since then.
I can understand that, the whole Emotive/Amotive crap was put out to end thier record contract obligations, and they were garbage in my opinion. APC is awesome live, I love the first two albums, but I prefer the heaviness and odd time changes of Tool.