Vieja Argentea experience,anyone...?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
mark377;4296571; said:
slow growers? most viejas are pretty fast growers I believe, my Blackbelt went from 2 inch to 11inch in little over a year.

Blackbelts are an entirely different species.

My argentea grew from 2" to 11" in three years. I've yet to see one in the 14-16" range that everyone claims they grow to. I've only seen 2-3 over 12".

They're pretty aggressive to fish with similar body shape and colors. I had issues keeping my male with a smaller argentea in a 220, and practically impossible to keep him with a female in a 6' tank.
 
I picked mine up when he was around 6". It took him about a year and a half to reach 12". He was pretty aggressive towards other larger fish, but didn't bother smaller less aggressive ones. Make sure to feed him plenty of spirulina-enriched foods.
 
I have had Argenteas before and find that if you put them in a tank that is established already with other fish, they will not be as aggresive. But if you put them alone in a tank and then try to add more fish, good luck with that. You'll be buying fish every other day.
 
Modest_Man;4297458; said:
Blackbelts are an entirely different species.
They are closely related so I think he was just using it as an example of around how fast they grow. But I think genes and dominance play a big role.
 
When someone asks for advice on a growth rate for a certain species, don't give information for a different species. Blackbelts grow like weeds, argentea don't.
 
Modest_Man;4300108; said:
When someone asks for advice on a growth rate for a certain species, don't give information for a different species. Blackbelts grow like weeds, argentea don't.
Where did I say that Argentea's grow fast? I only said viejas are fast growers I believe.. jesus
 
mark377;4300272; said:
Where did I say that Argentea's grow fast? I only said viejas are fast growers I believe.. jesus

Perhaps you should re-read the title of this thread.
 
Adhlc;4300368; said:
Perhaps you should re-read the title of this thread.
Yes I dont have experience with Argentea, I was just comparing him to another Vieja, like I already mentioned I only said they grow fast "I believe", but never mind, cause this discussion is ruining the thread
 
I appreciate everyones advice and am sorry if this thread took a LEFT somewhere. But again, I really appreciate it and that is what makes this site so darn good....so many opinions and experiences. Love it.....!
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com