Honestly, it doesn't matter. A solid axle yoda is a perfectly capable rig. A little on the heavy side compared to a jeep, but still capable. Building a truck is a slippery slope. You start out with a lift, tires, and maybe a few engine mods... next thing you know, you are having a hard time finding stock parts on your truck. It doesn't really matter where you start, as long as it is done right. Mine is more Currie/ rough country than jeep. For trail riding, the jeep is the better option. It is smaller, lighter, and more maneuverable. It will get into tighter spaces without ripping the mirrors off.
Some could argue that a yoda could have less failures. Most failures come from neglect, not engineering flaws. They will be equally reliable if properly built and maintained. Any aftermarket part can break on either rig. A Jeep is going to be cheaper to build. A yoda will be more comfortable and will have more interior space. Gas milage is irrelevant on large mud tires. Personally, I would go with the Jeep. But thats just me.
Some could argue that a yoda could have less failures. Most failures come from neglect, not engineering flaws. They will be equally reliable if properly built and maintained. Any aftermarket part can break on either rig. A Jeep is going to be cheaper to build. A yoda will be more comfortable and will have more interior space. Gas milage is irrelevant on large mud tires. Personally, I would go with the Jeep. But thats just me.
