Though I do agree that the vocal minority of fishkeepers that heavily criticize overstocked tanks (sometimes to the point of denigration) can often be rather unjust, I don't think that applies in this case. OP posted an almost laughably ridiculous question and got a unanimous answer (that really should've been apparent to anyone with sufficient experience to keep half those fish on the list) delivered both respectfully and somewhat rudely (moreso the latter than the former, in all fairness); instead of treating the responses seriously, he immediately went to criticizing some of the users as if he was superior in some way. Then he barges into random threads and continues insulting experienced members, calling people "invalids" and "12-14 year olds" and so on and so forth. Also appears to have an incredibly overinflated ego; he keeps believing that others are jealous of him and tells others to "quit bragging". The advice he gives is also often false or poorly-advised, and sometimes even goes to the point of pointing out nonexistent issues for the sake of showing off his "intelligence". Even went as far as to call MFK "his" forum.My take on the situation is that the original poster probably doesn't speak English as his first language. Secondly, I believe that he is from a country that appreciates a well stocked tank.
He started two threads with the same name, and was promptly attacked both times. I totally understand why he would be edgy in his other replies.
If the OP is Asian, it would make complete sense. In many of the Asian countries people treat each other with a high deal of respect. Western cultures are incredibly rude by comparison.
When I joined MFK (many years ago), the Stocking Police were already in full force. Today they are still going strong. A very beautiful and heavily stocked tank was frequently referred to as the worst case of over stocking, however a few of us recognized the merit in the tank. The owner was very successful in maintaining the health of the fish, and he was very knowledgeable about the equipment running the tank. At the time, tank owner was known as Too Spicy Noodle. (Raise your hand if you recognize the name.) Today he goes by a different name, but it is my understanding that he still frequents MFK.
if the OP was treated differently, I think he would have reacted differently too. If he is an experienced aquarist like Too Spicy Noodle, then he may be able to teach MFK a great deal.
...or maybe he's just a snot nosed brat.
You alright dude?Wow ok this is a lot to unpack. JMP really don’t do well in glass aquariums as they bite hard, it seems you’re aware of that though.
That being said you are remarkably uneducated and possibly daft. I hope you don’t have kids in the house with the JMP. Don’t add anything And get rid of that fish as soon as possible. You are a sick man.