This black under exposed area fill more or less of the frame depending on the shutter speed. As soon as it gets faster than 1/200 it will incrementally fill the frame with this darker underexposed area. So not something I can eliminate with other settings if I wanted faster shutter speed than 1/200? Not sure why I'd want faster shutter speed, just curious. Has definitely seemed like aperture is the biggest contributor to exposure.
So reducing aperture is going to reduce exposure (I think), reducing ISO compensates for that?