What do you feed your fish?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

fishblahblah

Jack Dempsey
MFK Member
Sep 1, 2014
107
26
36
PA
What do you feed your fish? Do you change their staple food as they hit different stages in life? Do you feed high protein (above 45%) pellets/flakes or do you prefer a lower protein food? What changes in growth/color/tank maintenance do you notice with which types of food?
 
Most cichlids need the protein most, when they young, but some change to a more vegetarian, omnivorous diet as they age.
Especially some like bocourti and pearsei become almost totally vegetarian as adults.
Vieja often eat fallen fruit like figs when adults.
Some predators also change as they age.
There is even a study of the gut contents of dovii as they age, and when young they eat almost exclusively small fish but as adults eat mostly large insects and crustaceans.
[/URL[URL=http://s70.photobucket.com/user/dstuer/media/Etroplus/secondsuraten/dandelion/IMG_1219_zpsd85vrp0y.jpg.html][/URL]
 
My favorite food to feed is NLS Algaemax. It comes in wafers or small pellets. It has more non-terrestrial based plant/algae/seaweed varieties than any food I've seen by far and yet it's primary ingredient is still whole anarctic krill. I feed it to both my oscar and my jack dempseys. My smaller cichlids get the NLS all purpose formula.

Algaemax comes in a small pellet size and a larger algae wafer size. The wafer size is great for large cichlids, but for medium size SA and CA the small 3mm pellet is best.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RD.
I try to feed my fish a wide variety of foods. In the morning, I feed a mixture of NLS Thera+, Northfin pellets, Fluval Herbivore pellets, and Aqueon sinking pellets. In the evening, I feed either frozen cubes, live earthworms and ghost shrimp when available, or romaine lettuce and zuchinni. I've noticed that as my Pearsei has aged she doesn't eat the frozen bloodworms/brine shrimp cubes that she used to love when she was growing. NLS has the best mixture of ingredients imo but NONE of my fish, current or past, have taken to it right away. They deal with it eventually but I have noticed a decrease in growth rates since switching. It's probably due to the fact that they don't gorge themselves on the NLS.
 
Right now I am feeding NLS cichlid pellets as a staple with freeze dried krill or some southern delight veggie food I have to mix it up. I usually feed the nls (or hikari for my adult cichlids) and switch up the "snack food" when one runs out
 
Looks like NLS is the favorite so far. I've heard of Southern Delight but never tried it before.
 
F7D3C96F-9B2E-4368-A15D-8DCA0C8FC7E5.jpeg

So, as you can see I use alittle bit of everything. I’m actually one of those guys that only feeds once a day. And even skips days now and again. Instead of feeding multiple times a day. I try to keep them eating a variety of foods. Not just the same thing every time.

Ive actually met the owner/ creator of southern delight. He is...an interesting fellow who lives in my hometown here in Sarasota. My smaller fish love the veggietai color micro pellets. But as far as ingredients go. It’s mid tier I’d say, and if you leave any excess in the tank it will turn white almost immediately. I still use good old flakes for my angel fish and Betta. Although I treat them with black worms, blood worms, and live brine shrimp from time to time.

My larger cichlids get the Larger pellets. With treats of crickets, brine shrimp, cut fish, cut gulf shrimp, worms, ghost shrimp, and a chopped vegetable every now and then.

What it boils down to is, how much do you want to do for your fish food. I’ve raised fish for years and years with nothing but pellets. But honestly I enjoy giving them different things every now and then. I feel NSL and Hikari both make solid products and are always the core of my lineup sort of speak.

But I’m always reading the backs of new foods or trying different things out. For instance the last bag on the right is a brand I’ve never heard of. So far my fish don’t love it. It’s got decent ingredients but is too expensive so it doesn’t knock hikari or nsl off the top.
 
I’ve been feeding my juvenile Oscar and firemouths hikari Cichlid gold mini pellets and brine shrimp. Probably feed them some veggies and other food in the future.
 
My favorite food to feed is NLS Algaemax. It comes in wafers or small pellets. It has more non-terrestrial based plant/algae/seaweed varieties than any food I've seen by far and yet it's primary ingredient is still whole anarctic krill. I feed it to both my oscar and my jack dempseys. My smaller cichlids get the NLS all purpose formula.

Algaemax comes in a small pellet size and a larger algae wafer size. The wafer size is great for large cichlids, but for medium size SA and CA the small 3mm pellet is best.

+1

I don't post a lot about nutrition these days as quite frankly I got tired dealing with the mental midgets of the internet, those that would argue corn, soybeans, dried bakery products, and even peas, are somehow nutritionally superior to aquatic based plant matter. It defies logic, but so does a lot of what one reads on online forums.

NLS has once again taken the lead in fish nutrition with their AlageMax formula. This has become the main staple to my more herbivorous species, as well as a reasonable portion of the diet of all of my fish. All of my fish eat it with great gusto, I have never had a fish not hammer it hard. Various cichlids, loaches, catfish, etc.

The other formula that I have been feeding a lot of is the NLS UltraRed. Not for the red color enhancing properties so much, I even feed this to solid blue fish, catfish, etc. I feed it for its high carotenoid content, which acts as an immune booster. All of my fish go crazy over it. With krill/squid/fish as the main ingredients, why wouldn't they?

http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1095643314000658

Apart from their role as antioxidants, carotenoids may also enhance the immune system through increased T-cell activation, macrophage capacity and lymphocyte proliferation (Bendich and Olson, 1989; Pérez-Rodríguez, 2009).

However, there is considerable support for two predictions of the carotenoid trade-off hypothesis (reviewed in Blount and McGraw, 2008; Svensson and Wong, 2011). The first is that carotenoid supplementation increases coloration, immunity and/or antioxidant capacity (Hill et al., 2002; Blount et al., 2003; Clotfelter et al., 2007). The second is that immune challenges, which also cause oxidative stress, cause re-allocation of carotenoids and reduce coloration of carotenoid-pigmented structures (Perez-Rodriguez et al., 2010; Toomey et al., 2010).


As Duane pointed out, higher protein foods are generally reserved for fry and young juveniles, certainly not adults. A lot of hobbyists seem confused about the protein (and fat) requirements of captive raised ornamental fish. The reality is most hobbyists most likely are already feeding beyond the nutrient requirements of their fish, so high protein and/or fat diets are not doing your fish any favours. And simply eye balling a fish won't tell you what is going on inside, such as fatty infiltration of the liver, or over time heavy vacuolation, severe necrosis of the liver, pancreas, and spleen. The fish dies years later (prematurely), and short of a proper necropsy no one is the wiser. The fish simply gets replaced, with a new pet.


This is not to say that one can't have nice looking, healthy fish on other foods and brands, of course they can. But at the same time it makes no sense to me to stick ones head in the sand and support the science and logic of 40 years ago. Brand name recognition only goes so far, at least with me, and I have fed and trialed almost all of the different brands over the years.

Last but not least, buy in bulk whenever possible, not in smaller LFS jar sizes. Buying in bulk is by far the most cost effective manner in which to purchase commercial fish food. Let's face it, no matter what brand you buy it all adds up over the long haul. And just like the more premium dog/cat foods currently on the market, one can feed a lot less of the premium fish foods, compared to those that are heavy on the grain/carb side.
 
NLS is the only pellet I feed to my fish these days. I find pellets are perfect for my babies and adolescent fish to ensure a nutrient dense and varied diet. My larger predators get occasional pellet feedings for supplementation.

NLS nutrient lineup is the best I have found, it's also cheaper in bulk than most other products are in smaller sizes. This is an easy decision for me.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com