After going to school for environmental science, with a focus on water technology, and treatment, then working at a water treatment (filtration) plant for almost 20 years, and keeping fish over double that time, I am convinced no one media or style of filtration is any better than another, the important part is maintenance, and water changes.
My current tank uses the media that came with the tank (bio-balls, rings, lava rock for bio, a bio rocker, and floss and porrett foam for mechanical) although I have added shells from the beach as buffers, and turned one sump into an algae scrubber refugium. But in the past, I have used moving beds, bio-wheels, and they all work just as well as others, as long as they are kept up to speed, anything works as long as regular, frequent maintenance is done. If a filter (mechanical, and bio) is allowed to gunk up, it becomes useless, and spews nitrate.
never heard of sea shells as media. I suppose as a ph buffer? What type of shells do you use and how do you preprare it?


