I'm not sure about why they float or not but I do suspect that they had something to do with my payara dying in the past.I have tried numerous times to keep red tail tats and armatus before and once getting them off of live foods I would feed them smelt,much like the cuts you have pictured.I noticed that none of them would live for more than a year and I could not figure out what the cause of death was.Fast forward to now and I have what I've vowed to be my last armatus and it has been going strong for well over two years now and I have never fed it smelt,only raw shrimp,tilapia and catfish fillet.Other than the feeding,I don't do anything else any different than I did with the others payara...Maybe I'm on to something and maybe not but I just thought it was worth mentioning.