What's with live feeders

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Nabbig2

Fire Eel
MFK Member
May 28, 2007
2,602
6
68
California
I understand that having your carnivore fish's main diet be live feeders, especially goldfish, is not healthy for them, and really not nutritious. But don't many carnivorous fish eat other fish as a staple, too? I know they eat other things like crayfish, but I just don't really get it.
 
my pacu and oscar have a verry wide range of foods they get fresh fruit and veggies and about every two months i get seven feeders they love them and for a treat for the past week they have each gotten two blue berrys after there normal flakes.
 
the problem is not "live feeder fish". the problem is what KIND of "live feeder fish".

goldfish are not nutritious and very prone to parasites due to the conditions they're raised/kept.

in the wild, predators that prey on other fishes will likely eat a wide variety of "ilve feeder fish", while in the aquarium, the most commonly available feeders are goldfish and minniows which are as good as you eating letteuce.
 
i feed a variety, Crayfish, Nightcrawlers, Goldfish, Rossies, Various minnows from the Potomac, and some pellets
 
If you were to house the feeders in a seperate tank, feed them very well for a few months and then feed them to your fish, that would be different. Fact is that feeders are shipped to stores in overcrowded, ammonia filled bags. They are then often placed in tanks too small for their volume and not fed. By the time they hit your tank, they are starved, stressed and in many cases, days or less away from dying on their own.
In the wild, many fish are more opportunistic in their eating of live fish. They pick off babies, injured or diseased fish, while primarily consuming vegetable matter, fruits, insects and anything else they come across.
 
Feeding goldfish on a regular basis is like you eating at McDonalds on a regular basis. I use convicts for feeders, but on a limited basis. VAriety is the key to fish diet.
 
ewurm;985877; said:
Feeding goldfish on a regular basis is like you eating at McDonalds on a regular basis. I use convicts for feeders, but on a limited basis. VAriety is the key to fish diet.

Lol, wow! What do you feed your convicts to?
 
plus some fish will only eat live fish....

like some payaras and cudas:(
 
I feed my fish 4-6 inch African cichlids on a regular basis.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com