Which one would you keep?

[Camphilophus]

agreed. because theyre short bodies, they arent going to grow too quickly so you have some time to get that tank you were talking about. its a win win

good point I didn't think about that. They max out at what like 10"? They could live divided in a 55+ comfortably for a while.

 

[geodem]

i would keep both , nice SB's !

 

[BigBoi01]

Thanks for all of your input... I really do appreciate it. I will divide them until I get a larger tank ( I'm thinking a 90 gallon)... You guys rock LOL