Well wes - the best out there pound for pound is probably Mayweather yes. His out of the ring persona is pretty dislikable, he tries hard to be charismatic and also talk trash, but he's crap at it. It comes across as annoying and contrived, as opposed to someone like mayo who is more of a natural trash talker.
But in the ring? He'd bash everyone from 140 to 154 realistically. Very very good fighter, he doesn't have many flaws. Fast feet, fast hands, brilliant reactions, tight defense. Even up close, his chin is almost always covered by his shoulder, and he rolls with the punches well.
His punching power is not great, but certainly good enough to get opponents respect.
He's fighting zab judah on saturday. Zab is probably the fastest fighter, and maybe the hardest 1 shot puncher he's faced but zab is just too full of holes. Sloppy, lacks concentration, not overly skilled etc.
I'd like for zab to win but mayweather probably stops him in 8 or 9 rounds.
The only other candidates for best fighter are past it now. Hops around the time he beat tito was one of the best P4P, but he's over 40 and way past prime now. Same as morales, he used to be one of the very best but he's just got too many miles on him now, too many wars.
How about you? Who do you like? For the past few years my favourite active fighters have been diego corrales and erik morales and of course the pride of Asia Manny Pacquiao
If any other fighter had KO'd Morales I would have been really upset, but I can;t hate pacman, he's great. He's like a pitbull with fists.
I can't believe he started his career as a flyweight, and now he's KOing people like barrera and morales at junior lightweight. He's some fighter.
Although mayweather is of course more rounded and skilled, pacman is up there in the P4P rankings, without a doubt.