Why Is It So Taboo For Someone Telling How Much They Bought A Fish For.

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

ArttyFish

Candiru
MFK Member
May 22, 2008
678
10
48
The Land Of Fish Lovers
I have really noticed People are so hard nosed and tight lipped about how much they bought a certain fish for. Not necessarily the common everyday LFS fish, but the more rare, pricey everybody want types of fish, Asian Aros, Rare Peacock Bass, Fresh Water Stingrays, Siamese Wide Bar Dats?
Is it because most people don't want to say honestly what they paid for a fish to kind of devalue their fish just in case they might want to sell it to someone else in the future and they don't want to hear the buyer say" Hey, you only paid so and so originally for the fish, how come you selling it to me for that price"? Is it because the seller wants to get every last cent he can from the buyer so if he posted a said going price for the fish, he would have to honor the posted price? In example, the Asian Aro breeders in Asia will show you what they are breeding with pics, but they sure as hell wont reply to a "how much are you selling that Aro for?" question. Or say someone bought a nice pick up from a hooked up deal but will not tell any one who wants to know how much they got it for. I see tons of threads like this all the time when people reply asking how much the OP got a rare fish for and the questions is always ignored. Is it because rare fish prices can change at anytime of the week depending on demand and from people posting how awesome it is or praising a certain species? Kind of like a flavor of the week in Rare Fishkeeping? One week it's Armatus, one week it's Kelberi's, one week it's Goliath African Tiger fishes, another its Leopoldi rays.
Bottom line is I just wish more people would just be more open and share what they paid for a certain new fish in their collection. The subject is always tip toed around with.
 
A few reasons off the top of my head. 1) People might be embarassed by the amount they spent on a fish. 2) They might want people to admire their fish for its awesomeness and not its price tag. 3) It can accidently sound like bragging when talking about spending so much on a fish and people want to remain modest. 4) Not really anyone elses business besides the buyer and seller.
 
odd, the forums i hang out in and the people i actually talk to about their collection always toss out the price no hesitation. however, i wouldn't care if they didn't want to divulge such info. madding is right about the reasons they might not want to share.
 
Because if I sell you an albino stingray for $3000 because I like you, then how do I explain to Jos Shmoe I'm asking $8000 for the other albino stingray? You've got to realize that sellers don't wonder IF customers will play games, whine, and report them to monitoring agencies, they have to calculate HOW OFTEN customers will find something to whine about and then take steps to reduce the frequency of such instances. Disclosing prices is like giving one child a huge ice cream and the next child a tiny one and expecting both to be happy. Best to keep it confidential so everybody is happy with their ice cream.
 
Madding;4920198; said:
A few reasons off the top of my head. 1) People might be embarassed by the amount they spent on a fish. 2) They might want people to admire their fish for its awesomeness and not its price tag. 3) It can accidently sound like bragging when talking about spending so much on a fish and people want to remain modest. 4) Not really anyone elses business besides the buyer and seller.

Thanks Madding those are all great reasons for buying a very expensive fish direct from the vendor. But what about say if you bought a rare fish from a close friend or private party? For example if I sold you a 12 inch Kelberi for $50. It is just for natural curiosity members would want to know or be excited for your new fish and ask you, "Cool fish bro, may I ask you what you got it for?"
I know I sometimes feel inclined to ask a fellow member how much he/she pick up a nice fish I like for. Would you personally would you just say "yeah, my friend hooked me up for $50." or would you tell the MFK member " Hey, Mind Your Own Business!"
I know when it comes to me personally ,I am up front and honest and would tell anyone my honest answers. These are just honest true questions of mine when it comes to fish keeping and I don't know why it would create any controversy. I hope other members here knows what I mean or if I am the only one who doesn't understand my topic.
 
I usually don't mind telling a price. In the least I will PM them and just not answer in the thread. Perhaps more people are doing that then you realize, and it just looks like they're all being ignored (unless you yourself have had it happen to you multiple times).
 
knifegill;4920214; said:
Because if I sell you an albino stingray for $3000 because I like you, then how do I explain to Jos Shmoe I'm asking $8000 for the other albino stingray? You've got to realize that sellers don't wonder IF customers will play games, whine, and report them to monitoring agencies, they have to calculate HOW OFTEN customers will find something to whine about and then take steps to reduce the frequency of such instances. Disclosing prices is like giving one child a huge ice cream and the next child a tiny one and expecting both to be happy. Best to keep it confidential so everybody is happy with their ice cream.

Ballinouttacontrol, Knifegill, you both have a very solid point, thanks for the replies. I acknowledge and understand both your points.
I just think that Buying and selling rare fishes is just like playing the stock market. Value up one day, Value down another. Who is to put an exact value on a fish? I guess it is up to the supplier who actually goes out and collects these rarer fishes to start out with a price they think is "Market Value" and when Vendors get them, they analyze the market and see how "desired" a particular species is and bumps the price up to meet "Supply and Demand" but also I feel is a factor, how much excitement hobbyist have of that species at any given week.
 
Madding;4920234; said:
I usually don't mind telling a price. In the least I will PM them and just not answer in the thread. Perhaps more people are doing that then you realize, and it just looks like they're all being ignored (unless you yourself have had it happen to you multiple times).

No I have been the rare fish game quite a few years and I know better not to ask. That is why I have started this topic. It is just inquiring why it is so Taboo to open talk about rare fish prices.
I think the answer has to be "How much did that fish cost?"
Answer "As much as I can get for it at this exact time!"
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com