Why should I have to pay under warranty?????

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Here is an example of the warranty on my canister filter:

"The mfg. offers a 3 year warranty from the date of purchase against defects in material or workmanship under normal aquarium usage and service.
We offer a 3 year warranty on all non-replaceable parts which means that the filter will be repaired or replaced at the manufacturer's discretion, free of charge, when the complete pump is returned with proof of purchase and postage paid. Please include $4 (U.S.) to cover shipping and handling.
This warranty does not apply to any filter that has been subjected to misuse, negligence, or tampering."

The warranty seems rather straightforward but for the average consumer it is a maze of legalese because the words in the warranty can have a different meaning in the law then they do in everyday conversation.:screwy:

Warranties, IMO, are meant to be difficult to understand, offer minimal recourse to the consumer, especially for lower price products, and can be difficult for the consumer to prove that the mfg. is at fault for the failure of the product.

I agree with you that it can be more expensive to pack the item and ship it back then the item costs brand new. I will also hazard a guess that most people won't even bother. We are living in a throw away society. People want to pay the least amount of money they possibly can for a product because they need to stretch their dollars further.

But that is not to say that reputable manufacturer's are willing to lose the business of their customers by making inferior products, that would be a poor business choice. Sometimes it is the customer service that sucks and you just need to be a bit more vocal to get your shipping costs returned. Bad mouthing a company rarely gets anything positive accomplished so I'm not suggesting that route or inferring that the OP is or should be doing that.

I do believe that a company should stand behind their product and make the customer whole by either reimbursing their out of pocket expenses to repair/replace a defective item under warranty or offering them credit toward a similar product. I know this is done with recalled items and poor (bad) production runs of new products but it doesn't always happen fast. Just think of all the customers that don't know their defective item was recalled and they could have been entitled to a refund but have since avoided that manufacturer's products!! The squeaky wheel often does get the oil it needs.
 
FWIW, Dr.s Foster & Smith will send out a return shipping label. I had a heater cut out on me. They seem to be pretty good to me. - N
 
Thanks everyone for the responses. Deeda you made some excellent points. let me put the story out there I'll try to keep it short. I bought this canister and have been using it. No leaks good flow most of the time. The problem is air keeps building at the top of the canister and I have to tip it back and forth a couple times a day to cler the air or the flow goes way down. The manufacture has replaced Input and output in case of a crack thought it might be sucking air. I've replaced gaskets and seals as I was told this filter has to be put back together just right or it will get allot of air. It runs quiet and great as long as I do the tipping to each side everyday which is getting old fast. Thing is this is a massive filter and the cost to ship it from my neck of the woods will be high. I havn't been back in this long enough to just have a extra canister to use while this is off being fixed. So my only solution I can see is to spend another $$$ to replace this one and ship the old one when I have the Extra $$.
 
Hawkerw, I'm going to assume the canister filter you are having problems with is the reason you started this thread in the first place. If this is true, and you haven't gotten satisfaction dealing with customer service, it wouldn't be unreasonable to ask for assistance from the members of this forum.

I've seen your other posts regarding the 3 canister filters you own, and if this one is one of those, I'm sure we should be able to help you troubleshoot your problem since those filters are owned by a lot of members.

As a side note, all filters need to be assembled properly for them to work as designed. Canister filters are no different and the seals & o-rings are considered wear items and must be installed correctly to prevent air from being drawn into the filter during operation. Also, the filter media and its proper orientation in the filter may be part of your issue.

Sometimes it is just a simple step or slight change that is needed to get the filter operating properly so please let us help you troubleshoot your problem.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com