Why would you save this man? Would you?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Mess up the surgery?

  • Yes

    Votes: 24 45.3%
  • No, let him live

    Votes: 29 54.7%

  • Total voters
    53
Stone Like Fish;2042216; said:
So whats your opinion on the Iraq war huh...?

soldiers sign to die, terrorists make the same choice.
 
in general if any person can save a man's life, he has to save the man's life
there is no other way to think about it
else there would be no difference between that person and the murderer
 
as a doctor, i would not be able to live with myself knowing i killed another person-no matter what they did. i would do everything i could to fix him, and hope the judicial system puts him away for life.

you also dont know his state of mind-if he was truly psychotic and not taking his psychotropic meds-he may have not known what he even did. he sounds like a true psych patient to me...

im not trying to justify what he did, but i work in psych-and we dont know the full story or the history of why this was brought on.. i just cant see any perfectly sane person knowingly doing this..
 
The wheel is round. Some people using monster truck wheels, others merely a shopping cart wheel.

If the doctor chose to intentionally not save the man's life would he be any better than that man?
 
Me personally, I think I wouldnt help this guy out. But, a doctor has no choice. They did the oath and have to do it to the best of their abilities. So I voted Yes, but thats my personal opinion.

Doctors, have to help him live, thats the only way it can work.
 
Eh, living and suffering or leaving the suffering behind.. What would be a better punishment? Killing someone teaches them nothing..Might teach someone ELSE something, a loved one, for instance... but how can they learn from dying? Nothing.
I hope he's a cutie, if he goes to jail they'll love him..
 
That was a sickening story....
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com