Will an RTC develop better color if fed every other day as opposed to everyda

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

that_fish_Guy

Peacock Bass
MFK Member
Jul 29, 2013
2,087
315
122
29
CA
Just wondering if it's true because somebody told me this at a mom and pop kind of aquarium store that has many RTC's however I did not beleive them my RTC is around 10-12 inches or so and I still feed him everyday


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
I don't see how that would affect the color.

Sent from my SPH-L710 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
Oh ok because this Asian lady owns this little fish store and she says that if you don't feed them every day that it will make their color come out idk it's what ever I just either wanted to confirm or debunk this and I now know it's debunked


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
Might make a difference if she explained why or gave more details. Superficially, it does not make sense, as many curt statements do not... BUT...

I am guessing that, perhaps, what she wanted to say by this statement is that if one conducts an experiment, wherein the same amount of good quality food is fed in two sittings in two days or in one sitting in two days, the colors may come out better, faster with rarer feedings. Digestion is a tricky thing. I can (without any knowledge) speculate that the assimilation of pigments is a slower (different) process than the assimilation of other nutrients, e.g., because pigments are not broken down but absorbed as is. With everyday feedings, the food may be pushed through the tract a bit faster than with 1-in-2-days feedings, and the fish absorbs less and excretes relatively more pigments.

Sorry, this is a lot of water on the proverbial wheel and blah-blah-blah but I guess what I am trying to say is that one would be prudent to not dismiss the words of others right away without attempting to understand what they want to state and why.

As stated, the food must contain pigments in the right amount to be utilized by fish.

Moreover and on a slightly different angle, the main problem with sub-adult and adult RTCs is overfeeding which gives rise to digestion problems and deaths. On that note, one may feed everyday and not overfeed and one may feed once in two days and overfeed. The quantity is completely omitted from the OP and the discussion while it is crucial to it.
 
Might make a difference if she explained why or gave more details. Superficially, it does not make sense, as many curt statements do not... BUT...

I am guessing that, perhaps, what she wanted to say by this statement is that if one conducts an experiment, wherein the same amount of good quality food is fed in two sittings in two days or in one sitting in two days, the colors may come out better, faster with rarer feedings. Digestion is a tricky thing. I can (without any knowledge) speculate that the assimilation of pigments is a slower (different) process than the assimilation of other nutrients, e.g., because pigments are not broken down but absorbed as is. With everyday feedings, the food may be pushed through the tract a bit faster than with 1-in-2-days feedings, and the fish absorbs less and excretes relatively more pigments.

Sorry, this is a lot of water on the proverbial wheel and blah-blah-blah but I guess what I am trying to say is that one would be prudent to not dismiss the words of others right away without attempting to understand what they want to state and why.

As stated, the food must contain pigments in the right amount to be utilized by fish.

Moreover and on a slightly different angle, the main problem with sub-adult and adult RTCs is overfeeding which gives rise to digestion problems and deaths. On that note, one may feed everyday and not overfeed and one may feed once in two days and overfeed. The quantity is completely omitted from the OP and the discussion while it is crucial to it.

I took what she is saying as feeding less, to a point, will result in a healthier fish and therefore better coloration, which makes sense to me. Hard to say for sure without hearing it directly from her.
 
Color is in what you feed them.


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app

X10. Feed astaxanthin it will bring out the red more. The last rtc I had I would feed foods like hikari carnivore sinking pellets in the short time I used it the red was a lot darker. I would also break em in half and stuff them in market shrimp n tilapia. Make sure any pellets you feed have astaxanthin in it.


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
Thanks you guys I've really learned a lot from this little discussion thanks for sharing all of your insight and knowledge on this topic it really had me stumped haha


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
feed them lots of good quality food will help.
but most importantly, lots of good quality water change will make the big difference.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com