Your Honest OPinion if You Will.

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Whats your honest opinion?

  • It will be fine.

    Votes: 9 36.0%
  • It is over stocked.

    Votes: 9 36.0%
  • It is understocked

    Votes: 1 4.0%
  • Other Opinion, please state.

    Votes: 6 24.0%

  • Total voters
    25
  • Poll closed .
What's the point of having a stock tank with a few big catfish in? Maybe I'm weird, but it sounds pointless. You only see them when staring over the stock tank (for me one of the only purpose of a fish tank is too see and enjoy the fish), and it's too small to swim with the fishes in. If were you, I would just get an intex pool and put a layer of pond liner over it to be safe. Much bigger and cheaper.
 
I think I have the best help so far?
 
I used a 300 gal stock tank as an "Indoor Cichlid Pond" for years and was very happy with it. I'll admit the top view only was restrictive compared to a typical glass/acrylic aquarium, but the solid side walls seemed to make the fish feel more comfortable.

I found I could fit a whole lot of fish in it, although I was keeping 6~12" Cichlids and not 30" catfish. I think something this size would be okay (but not 'good') for one or two 30" cats, but not 5. The diameter of the tank is only a little over double the fishes length. It is quite true that they could swim in circles thus allowing them a much longer "linear path" but 5 large cats with 5 large hides they will be constantly running into one another which will likely interrupt their "linear path".

I have also seen some 8' round 700 gallon kiddie pools that I was very tempted to buy. I think the little bit of extra diameter would make a huge difference in your case.

As for filtration, I highly suggest you consider a Pressurized Pond Filter such as the BioForce 2000. I used this filter on my stock tank for years and was completely satisfied with it. It works well with up to an 1800 gph pump.
 
Thanks everyone.

I have re thought the stocking of the 300 gallon.
This is what Iam thinking 3 giant rapheals and 1 leiarius pictus.

Iam also thinking about checking out the pool sale at the end of summer.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com