Is a 135 big enough for a pbass ?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
The reality is that very very few hobbyists should be able to keep these fish.

A Pbass can live in a 55. That my not be the best, but they will live, correct?

The problem is these fish just are not ment for anyone but the sellect few.
so whats sufficient??

your 2000 pool seemed ideal

but would it be good for life??

i mean these suckers can reach 3ft, but ive yet to see that in capitivity (Home aquarium)
 
so whats sufficient??

your 2000 pool seemed ideal

but would it be good for life??

i mean these suckers can reach 3ft


after watching these fish in the wild, It will be hard for me to ever keep an individual over 10 inches in an aquairum. Which is why I will be constructing a very large pond.

I think once these fish get to a certain size, they are not kept correctly in anything smaller than a 20x20 foot space.

I feel this way about Baracuda, Trevially, dorado, and a couple other sellect fish that are built for 1 thing. speed.
 
The reality is that very very few hobbyists should be able to keep these fish.

A Pbass can live in a 55. That my not be the best, but they will live, correct?

The problem is these fish just are not ment for anyone but the sellect few.

True..but they are available to everyone...and they will continue to sell...we just have to live with that.

So instead of telling them to get 2000 gallon tanks...(because that is unrealistic and pointless)...I tell them to get something like a 96x30x24...because even that is better than a standard 240.

It probably is true when you say that only very very few hobbyists should be able to keep cichla...but we all know now... thats just not going to happen.
 
True..but they are available to everyone...and they will continue to sell...we just have to live with that.

So instead of telling them to get 2000 gallon tanks...(because that is unrealistic and pointless)...

unrealistic? pointless??

very realistic!!!

has a point!!!

If someone that was that truely dedicated to the hobby and well being of there cichla they would go out of there way to build and or buy a tank of the correct size. Regardless of the obstacles.

it can and should be done.

regardless of someone situation it is very realistic.
 
True..but they are available to everyone...and they will continue to sell...we just have to live with that.

So instead of telling them to get 2000 gallon tanks...(because that is unrealistic and pointless)...I tell them to get something like a 96x30x24...because even that is better than a standard 240.

It probably is true when you say that only very very few hobbyists should be able to keep cichla...but we all know now... thats just not going to happen.


You make a valid point. Also, I dont recomend a 2000gallon. I usually go for a 600+ for a few adults.

I consider a 2000gallon to small, for true adults. Especially large temensis and or Orinos.


If you must keep these fish in a tank. go for something bigger than 4 feet wide, and 8 feet long.
 
it can and should be done.


I built my pond at age 16.. on a LFS wage. If I can do it, Anyone can, with the correct drive.

Sure it wont look like that of a public aquarium, but it will be better for your fish than any tank.

DSC00546.JPG


checking out these pictures (of the pond) brings tears to my eyes. I really miss that set up and fish.
 
I built my pond at age 16.. on a LFS wage. If I can do it, Anyone can, with the correct drive.

Sure it wont look like that of a public aquarium, but it will be better for your fish than any tank.

DSC00546.JPG


checking out these pictures (of the pond) brings tears to my eyes. I really miss that set up and fish.

I have the drive....I just don't have an awesome room like that to set one up :(
 
I have the drive....I just don't have an awesome room like that to set one up :(

where do you live? move into a place with a garage. Settle for a crappy place, but one that has a garage. I would have no problems living in a tent if I cold have a house/garage full of fish ;)
 
I built my pond at age 16.. on a LFS wage. If I can do it, Anyone can, with the correct drive.

Sure it wont look like that of a public aquarium, but it will be better for your fish than any tank.

DSC00546.JPG


checking out these pictures (of the pond) brings tears to my eyes. I really miss that set up and fish.

did you sell it or you got it in storage?

Dude, you are awsome!
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com