Ok, I'm going to debunk all this wild and c.b. myth.
with the azuls: there is purportedly a breeder or two in Asia, but they have not produced any off spring yet. The ones shipped out of Brazil, which is the origin of cichla piquiti, some are wild caught and some are captive bred, mixed pretty much together, sent out of a couple of facilities., they breed them locally from wild stock, which really means they're still wild, since they're from the original waters, food, location and people. If from Asia then it would be a different story, and consider this F1 is is reality still wild fish, since the parents are wild and not related.
cichla kelberi "bahia" have a lot of yellow and gold, the one breeder who bred them made half a million dollars selling them, but the original pair was exceptional, it made cover of magazines, and posters., this breeder is a urban legend, he has millions of dollars worth of rare fish, I've seen with my own eyes. When these fish were first made available, people couldn't take their eyes off of them, and they sold so well, since most Asian people like the excessive gold, and red spangles on these fish. Now they're made more available, people are again wanting something different.
There are still some wild cichla kelberi that trickle out of South America, again not in large numbers, and the color out come will vary. Kelberi is one of the most widely distributed peacock bass in Brazil, found in many river systems, supposedly even at Rio DeJenairo
same with cichla melaniae, all the ones you see here are from maybe 2 breeders total, so the numbers as may seem high is just on MFK, most people in the country or world have never even heard of one yet.
Just think back, 10 years ago, there were no kelberi, piquiti, melaniae in the US at all! Appreciate what you have today!
Wes
Fugupuff. Well said.. So then what's the deal with rio arraguia kelberi ? Are they really wild or all captive ?
Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app