Species of cichla with HITH

[heatherbeast]

It won't let me click 'none'. I still feel like the number of those that have had versus those that have not are very important to get a better understanding of the PERCENTAGE of each type that gets it.

 

[HULON]

Agreed entirely. Thank you for your time!

I voted "other" as none of my pbass past or present ever had hole in the head. Keep good water,food and stress to minimum and you won't see HITH.

Oh and i got pictures documentation on the forum Do you????????????????????????

 

[CichlaRyan]

You both could not be more wrong and obviously have not kept cichla to adult stages meaning 2 feet plus and over half a decade But Love the discusion this is creating tho

I have had fish with HITH, I don't need "adult stages" to relate to the topic. And you're right I haven't had half a decade, I've had more. Furthermore how is it so obvious? What's with the jabs? Seems like you C.R.E.A.M guys have always had some sort of beef with logic.

 

[HULON]

I have had fish with HITH, I don't need "adult stages" to relate to the topic. And you're right I haven't had half a decade, I've had more. Furthermore how is it so obvious? What's with the jabs? Seems like you C.R.E.A.M guys have always had some sort of beef with logic.

Nooooo Ryan I beg to differ you have not kept the same fish or fishes 5 years or more and if you have show the proof i will say i am wrong meaning 2 feet or more and 5 years old.I have and have proof and to say an article or several articles written buy a guy or gal does not mean it is Gospel !!!I and yes i think age and size have a lot to do with it does not mean i am right it just means that is my opinion So Let's move on with a good discusion here fella's I know it can be a good 1 i have not been this exited for a while!!!!By the way Welcome back Ryan

 

[CichlaRyan]

Nooooo Ryan I beg to differ you have not kept the same fish or fishes 5 years or more and if you have show the proof i will say i am wrong meaning 2 feet or more and 5 years old.I have and have proof and to say an article or several articles written buy a guy or gal does not mean it is Gospel !!!I and yes i think age and size have a lot to do with it does not mean i am right it just means that is my opinion So Let's move on with a good discusion here fella's I know it can be a good 1 i have not been this exited for a while!!!!By the way Welcome back Ryan

So according to you, unless I have the same fish, for 5 years, and it's at least 2 feet long I can not relate to this thread? What, haha. Maybe you meant something else and I can't decipher it.

Sorry, call me dimwitted but I don't follow, what do you mean when you said "I have and have proof and to say an article or several articles written buy a guy or gal does not mean it is Gospel !!!" layman's terms please. I honestly don't understand.

I agree with the age and size of the individual fish having a direct impact to the susceptibility of the disease, no problem there.

And thanks, it's good seeing you too Hugh.

 

[HULON]

So according to you, unless I have the same fish, for 5 years, and it's at least 2 feet long I can not relate to this thread? What, haha. Maybe you meant something else and I can't decipher it.

Sorry, call me dimwitted but I don't follow, what do you mean when you said "I have and have proof and to say an article or several articles written buy a guy or gal does not mean it is Gospel !!!" layman's terms please. I honestly don't understand.

I agree with the age and size of the individual fish having a direct impact to the susceptibility of the disease, no problem there.

And thanks, it's good seeing you too Hugh.

Again Ryan I think maybe you and i are talking about different problems all together with the same result Ultimately I have never had trouble with cichla Oscar Uaru And many others at a young stage in life Ever!!!! with line disease But I am Now !!!!!!Does that make me better then another guy NOOOO!!!! Or worse NOOOO!!!!So come on Let's see what kind of result we can get!!!!

Also for some guy to say good water no problem !!!!! Is Like a fart in the wind it's a nothing statement!!!

And Ya Ryan i think it's a whole different world when Cichla reach their full size and potential a different game altogether!!!!

Hello Hello Hello Hello sure is quiet I am all ears Ryan Ya got some answers for us Cuz i tell ya i am just steamin about what i have done to her

 

[kamikaziechameleon]

Have 13 monos no HITH...

I've only ever had one fish with it, a G. tile eel and that was definitely because of my amateur diet I was feeding him.

 

[bassguy]

So according to you, unless I have the same fish, for 5 years, and it's at least 2 feet long I can not relate to this thread? What, haha. Maybe you meant something else and I can't decipher it.

Sorry, call me dimwitted but I don't follow, what do you mean when you said "I have and have proof and to say an article or several articles written buy a guy or gal does not mean it is Gospel !!!" layman's terms please. I honestly don't understand.

I agree with the age and size of the individual fish having a direct impact to the susceptibility of the disease, no problem there.

And thanks, it's good seeing you too Hugh.

Ok you've made your points and you are no longer helping the thread, move on please.

Hu had made a good point about no one wanting to come out on this because of all the know it all, I'm better than you, if you don't see it my way your wrong, people that just love to troll or bash. Now I see his point as clear as day, and don't blame him. I can say with a few others Hu is one of the best most devoted cichla keepers around and if his fish can get it, it can happen to anyone with "perfect water".

 

[bassguy]

Have 13 monos no HITH...

I've only ever had one fish with it, a G. tile eel and that was definitely because of my amateur diet I was feeding him.

How old and size?

 

[Pharaoh]

Keep the conversation about the topic at hand and not about who's got the bigger whatever. everyone is entitled to provide their input.