I guess not. History says Tebow was more successful his rookie year then Peyton.
If your gonna state what history says at least get it right. Tebow was not a rookie when he took Denver to the playoffs. He was in his second year, now go and find Mannings results from his second year. You'll see a huge difference between the two

Ok well we can. You had an injured Manning who missed an entire season with a career threatening injury that required 3 surgeries. Yet you had 6 teams chasing him and willing to sign him once the colts cut him loose. Now you have a healthy tebow and the only team willing to take a look was the Pats and they cut him.