does the weight of a fish increce tank weight?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

matty832012

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Feb 14, 2013
139
0
0
United States
thats is just it, all in the title, does the weight of the fish increase the weight of the aquarium or do they simply displace enough water to counter act them minus there bladder? is there equally no answer :)
 
If you had your aquarium + contents on a scale and the weight shown was 240 lb, and then you added a 1 lb fish, the scale would then read 241 lb,. Buoyancy is an 'internal' force between the fish and the water and has nothiing to do with the pull of gravity (ie. weight) externally on the whole works.
 
Less. Fish will displace water and fish weighs less then water.

Sent from my SM-N900W8 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
Given you want to keep water level exact you would have to remove the fishes displacement in water.

Sent from my SM-N900W8 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
If you had your aquarium + contents on a scale and the weight shown was 240 lb, and then you added a 1 lb fish, the scale would then read 241 lb,. Buoyancy is an 'internal' force between the fish and the water and has nothiing to do with the pull of gravity (ie. weight) externally on the whole works.
but would 1lb fish displace the 1lb of water? whats more dense?
 
Which weighs more, 10 lbs of stones, or 10 lbs of feathers?

Not the correct argument for this technically.

Tank filled with water to the brim, put the fish in and it spills some water. Now you have a fish, and a little less water. Figuring out if the water displaced and spilled on the floor with the now fish in it is where I don't know the weight. Depends on the density of the fish and displaced water. I can imagine that the fish being added is going to be equal or slightly less because the fish will not weigh as much as an exact replica of the fish made of pure water.

As said in a prior post too, if your tank doesn't over flow and you add any weight to it, the tank weighs more.
 
nice information not sure yet, it would seem to me that the fish would almost displace enough water to make up to its size. water being more dence then fish?
 
Birds are heavier than air. So if they stop flapping their wings they fall to the ground. If your fish stop swimming do they float to the top or sink to the bottom? We had this debate one time at work while I was building my tank. They could not understand that I do not fill my tanks to the level that if I put in a fish I need to take water out. Adding fish does not add any weight to the tank. unless you have really big fish and your tank is only half full and the fish is in a bag with 5 gallons of water. That gets dumped in the tank. What adds weight to the tank is gravel. When people ask me how heavy my fish tank is I tell them 10 pounds per gallon.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com