New wild axanthic??? Silver arowana from wes rare fish

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Status
Not open for further replies.
LMAO- risk getting hit by an arapaima! You have a better chance of getting struck by lightning.

These people aren't rich man! You think they have the means to build a pond, catch a bunch of arros, feed and take care of them everyday?
Or would it be easier for them to get in a boat they already have for fishing and go net some already to go, release the parent and catch them in the next breeding season. No need to take care of fish fighting in a pond, don't need to feed them, don't have to worry about floods or predation or vandalism. No worries, except for killer flying arapaima- ROTFLMA!
You've been watching way to many River Monster shows LOL


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app

Have you read the article before you posted, bro Fong? It said Asian arowana has been protected by CITES since 2006. Does that sound right to you, bro Fong? Or does the article sounds like a bunch of poorly collected information, without fact checking, verification? Where did you find it? Gossip column?

No reason for them to make up story. Really? Are you that naive, bro Fong? Do you also live under a rock like T1karkmann?

Hey Einstein, just because you catch a male with one Xanthic or more doesn't mean the gene came from the male- what about the female? Are you going to catch every female out there and question them
which one bred with this male? And even if you got them both there is no guarantee of getting Xanthic fry again.

And if they were captive bred and easily produced like you and BroFong say then there would be a lot more people selling them right? Shoot the market would be flooded! In fact I'm going to go to Petsmart and pick one up right now. SMH, you and BroFong need to make a third sequel to DUMB AND DUMBER #TREE


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app

Yes it is a nice fish and it doesn't matter if it's captive bred or not. But if you remember you said that you wouldn't buy one of these because they are bred all the time in farms around you and aren't worth anything? Do you remember saying that or do I have to go find the quote? Can you at least be man enough and say you were wrong? They aren't breeding these Xanthic silvers in captivity yet or the farm would be posting it all over the Internet for sales. At least admit that.


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app

Yes I did. I wouldnt want to own the yellow one. The light yellowish to white one i wouldn't mind. but again why such a big difference between the 2 fishes? Take a step back and think.
 
I think mods should close this........one day I will come back on and update.......give each other your email address and you can fight forever
 
1. Maybe it doesn't have to be closed, so we can keep this going but in a more positive manner, let me re-direct
2. Bro Fong, you have some experience in keeping arowana, but you came off offensive when you said that the fish is common and not worth keeping, when in fact you could not produce pictures of the same fish that you claim to be common. If your criteria is a white fish that is ok, but do no be little other people's fish, this thread was started to show off a fish we got and found it was interesting. If you say yellow ones are common or not worth keeping, I cannot find too many pictures of those either.

3. Tk1- again you came off offensive as well, in the past update you said the owner used a Nan light to enhance and show off the colors, but it wasn't, and you were not only not apologetic, but you started to say these fish are probably captive bred and not worth keeping. Well, I can tell you that your black rays are common, they kill them in the rivers where they're found, but I don't say that, its called basic decency. Unfortunately you keep arguing and being ornery.

4. as for captive breeding, like I said, I know that Asian arowanas have been bred for some 20 years plus now, but also its because Asian arowanas have always commanded hundreds up to thousands of dollars each, even in Asia for at least 20 years, so there was a lot of money involved. As for silver arowanas, historically they were always a 5-10 dollar each fish at a small size, so that is why no effort was ever made to mass produce them. In the past they actually just kill the adults for food and take the babies. also its not easy to transport an adult with the limited equipment they have to a breeding station. it would be difficult. I'm sure there are some efforts being made to breed them, but its not done regularly yet, and we're not seeing the results yet.
 
The claims
1) no captive breeding in Latin america
Counter claim : a link to "reef to rainforest media, a publisher of award winning magazines and books, stating captive breeding of silver in Colombia.
2) "reef to raise forest media" data on cites listing 2006 ban Asian Arowana Is incorrect.
Counter claim: a link to Wikipedia to show the same claim as" reef to rainforest media".

Proven wrong And again. If I were you, I would be so embrasssed by now.
1) Your link has not prove captive breeding of silver arowana, bro Fong. It only shows a picture of 2 guys standing in a field, no harvesting/collecting fry from pond.
2) Arowana is listed as endangered in 2006, but it has been on CITES long before 2006. Go and read those links you posted again bro Fong
You're right on one thing, though. You should be so embarrassed by now.
 
Yes I did. I wouldnt want to own the yellow one. The light yellowish to white one i wouldn't mind. but again why such a big difference between the 2 fishes? Take a step back and think.
Why the big difference between two fish? Care to share your thought, bro Fong?
 
Hey Einstein, just because you catch a male with one Xanthic or more doesn't mean the gene came from the male- what about the female? Are you going to catch every female out there and question them
which one bred with this male? And even if you got them both there is no guarantee of getting Xanthic fry again.

And if they were captive bred and easily produced like you and BroFong say then there would be a lot more people selling them right? Shoot the market would be flooded! In fact I'm going to go to Petsmart and pick one up right now. SMH, you and BroFong need to make a third sequel to DUMB AND DUMBER #TREE


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app

This was my whole point about lottery ticket
If you find a male holding fry like this you have a 50/50 chance that that gene came from the male holding the fry

You would have to be a total fool to throw a male back holding fry like this if its that rare


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
I think mods should close this........one day I will come back on and update.......give each other your email address and you can fight forever

Why would you want mods to close it
Is it because not everyone loves it


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
1. Maybe it doesn't have to be closed, so we can keep this going but in a more positive manner, let me re-direct
2. Bro Fong, you have some experience in keeping arowana, but you came off offensive when you said that the fish is common and not worth keeping, when in fact you could not produce pictures of the same fish that you claim to be common. If your criteria is a white fish that is ok, but do no be little other people's fish, this thread was started to show off a fish we got and found it was interesting. If you say yellow ones are common or not worth keeping, I cannot find too many pictures of those either.

3. Tk1- again you came off offensive as well, in the past update you said the owner used a Nan light to enhance and show off the colors, but it wasn't, and you were not only not apologetic, but you started to say these fish are probably captive bred and not worth keeping. Well, I can tell you that your black rays are common, they kill them in the rivers where they're found, but I don't say that, its called basic decency. Unfortunately you keep arguing and being ornery.

4. as for captive breeding, like I said, I know that Asian arowanas have been bred for some 20 years plus now, but also its because Asian arowanas have always commanded hundreds up to thousands of dollars each, even in Asia for at least 20 years, so there was a lot of money involved. As for silver arowanas, historically they were always a 5-10 dollar each fish at a small size, so that is why no effort was ever made to mass produce them. In the past they actually just kill the adults for food and take the babies. also its not easy to transport an adult with the limited equipment they have to a breeding station. it would be difficult. I'm sure there are some efforts being made to breed them, but its not done regularly yet, and we're not seeing the results yet.

There maybe hundreds of aros like this around but most go to Japan China Hong Kong Taiwan all country's that never post what they have on the Internet
The truth of the matter is if this fish was as good as you say it would have gone to Asia as they would have paid a lot more than Europe or the U.S. but the truth is they didn't want it that's why it landed in the U.S. no other reason

Yes my black rays are not rare at all but I can say I bred them my self and most of my rays was born in my tank by me





Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
MonsterFishKeepers.com