sheepshead..... in a freshwater pond?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

KATALEKEEPER

Dovii
MFK Member
Nov 18, 2020
783
695
105
Brooklyn, Ny
Ok I saw this and wow! Is it awesome. some guy has been keeping sheepshead in a freshwater pond for 15+ years! It would be an interesting thing for someone to try...9958.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Backfromthedead
I don't want to go off a supposition. Is there a proof these are sheepshead? Who is the guy? Where is this info coming from? Does he have convincing photos that these are indeed what he says they are?

They may be sheepshead, I don't mind. They can be other fish. Kind of remind me of sergeant major, or other striped fish...

Abudefduf-saxatilis-01.jpg
 
I don't want to go off a supposition. Is there a proof these are sheepshead? Who is the guy? Where is this info coming from? Does he have convincing photos that these are indeed what he says they are?

They may be sheepshead, I don't mind. They can be other fish. Kind of remind me of sergeant major, or other striped fish...

Abudefduf-saxatilis-01.jpg
I COMPLETELY agree. Can not be Sergeant majors. By the size, they look large. We need context.
 
the link here! I mean what other species of fish could it be tho. Not convicts, not seargent majors, not freshwater drum. Not many other striped species of fish that can live in the temperate enviroment of america or in freshwater
 
  • Like
Reactions: jjohnwm
Those do look like sheepshead, though I can’t zoom in without it becoming blurry. I also see a possible largemouth bass due to the horizontal stripe and black tail, and the other fish look like tilapia. I don’t think they can be in full fresh, but largemouth bass and I think some species of tilapia, can be in brackish water. My guess is this is brackish water, but I don’t know if they are in a pond without evidence.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com