Hornet cichlid for 1700 gallon pond

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
This is just another one of those threads...the ones where an aquarist just has to push the limits, gotta try balancing on the knife-edge of disaster just because. This size of tank, pond, whatever you call it, offers almost limitless possibilities for stocking all kinds of beautiful and interesting fish that will live peacefully together, without carnage. Why must it still be set up as a potential arena?

He may be pushing his options but hasn't gone through with it. He's doing what I was doing with my tank: exploring his options. In his size pond, he has many more options than I had (and I had plenty of options): he can even have an RTC long-term.

Fish-keeping is an art; in art, people constantly push boundaries and limits to see what they can do. Art is flexible; it has no rules and ultimately depends on the artist's vision. If he decides to push something and has the appropriate space for it, he can do so if he wants to; he can change it later, depending on how it works out. I will admit that fish-keeping is a more serious art than many forms because the artists are in charge of caring for living organisms, but it is still flexible. It is ultimately AR1's decision.

AR1@, as a fellow fishkeeper and friend, I recommend treading very carefully with the hornet if you must have it. If it isn't a highly desirable fish to you and you want something big to fill up the pond, I recommend researching some more options: arowanas would be cool, and maybe some more catfish. A smaller gar or two, perhaps? Stingrays?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: abominus
He may be pushing his options but hasn't gone through with it. He's doing what I was doing with my tank: exploring his options. In his size pond, he has many more options than I had (and I had plenty of options): he can even have an RTC long-term.

Fish-keeping is an art; in art, people constantly push boundaries and limits to see what they can do. Art is flexible; it has no rules and ultimately depends on the artist's vision. If he decides to push something and has the appropriate space for it, he can do so if he wants to; he can change it later, depending on how it works out. I will admit that fish-keeping is a more serious art than many forms because the artists are in charge of caring for living organisms, but it is still flexible. It is ultimately AR1's decision.

AR1@, as a fellow fishkeeper and friend, I recommend treading very carefully with the hornet if you must have it. If it isn't a highly desirable fish to you and you want something big to fill up the pond, I recommend researching some more options: arowanas would be cool, and maybe some more catfish. A smaller gar or two, perhaps? Stingrays?
thanks
 
  • Like
Reactions: SilverArowanaBoi
a lot of you mentioned that the hornet cichlid can cause problems, so i decided to go for a jaguar cichlid. can i add that to my pond. i will grow it out first in my tank
That’s like saying a lion wouldn’t be a good pet, but maybe a tiger would. Each are some of the most aggressive cichlids out there, so neither are good at sharing space. Beyond that, jags don’t get much bigger than buttis last I checked, so is still an easy meal.
Furthermore, cichlids aren’t great pond fish as they are naturally camouflaged from above.
 
That’s like saying a lion wouldn’t be a good pet, but maybe a tiger would. Each are some of the most aggressive cichlids out there, so neither are good at sharing space. Beyond that, jags don’t get much bigger than buttis last I checked, so is still an easy meal.
Furthermore, cichlids aren’t great pond fish as they are naturally camouflaged from above.

Agreed with Deadeye@, Maybe get some giant gouramis, or koi. Koi are bred to be looked down from the top; they were bred for ponds.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: abominus
That’s like saying a lion wouldn’t be a good pet, but maybe a tiger would. Each are some of the most aggressive cichlids out there, so neither are good at sharing space. Beyond that, jags don’t get much bigger than buttis last I checked, so is still an easy meal.
Furthermore, cichlids aren’t great pond fish as they are naturally camouflaged from above.
Agreed with Deadeye@, Maybe get some giant gouramis, or koi.
then i will probably buy a baby silver arowana and grow it out. would that be fine since my pond water temperature is a bit cold
 
then i will probably buy a baby silver arowana and grow it out. would that be fine since my pond water temperature is a bit cold

Grow out the Arowana In the 50-gallon tank, not in the pond. It will be a quick, expensive snack for your pacu and larger catfish.
 
  • Like
Reactions: abominus
Grow out the Arowana In the 50-gallon tank, not in the pond. It will be a quick, expensive snack for your pacu and larger catfish.
yeah i know that but i am worried about the water temp once it gets bigger
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com