2nd fish died, From the same incident

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
It's not your fault lol don't listen to them. Reef tanks don't have lids as a rule. Salt water is a better insulator than fresh and with a salt tank running through twice the amount of pumps, it overheats easily. Not having a lid IS your safeguard. Unless its an eel or octopus tank (which it's not or you wouldn't have clownfish). Sometimes fish commit suicide. If your params are spot on, you can chalk it up to bad luck. To be honest, I've never seen a clownfish jump for any reason other than running from a predator. What's your other stock and tank size?


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app

Thank you very much man!

The tank is a 20g and the only stock was 2 Clowns (As you've guessed they both jumped) 1 Cleaner Shrimp, Like 2 small hermits and about 2-3 Snails, Only 2 corals since I'm only starting with corals and they are a Button Polyp and a torch. As for Hitchhikers there is a small astrea Star, Sponge and a mussel of some sort.
 
There's your problem man. Check all your levels with a reef master kit. Most likely the torch coral is stressed and released stinging cells in the water. Torches are listed as an aggressive coral and can sting tankmates under stress.


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
There's your problem man. Check all your levels with a reef master kit. Most likely the torch coral is stressed and released stinging cells in the water. Torches are listed as an aggressive coral and can sting tankmates under stress.


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app

Alright, Will do though the torch seems to be fully out at a lot of times but I'll test.

Just out of curiosity, I thought Clowns were like 'sting proof'? Meaning they can host Anemones and corals without feeling the sting cells? Just curious
 
is your tank rimless? You can buy a "light diffuser panel" at home depot and cut it to fit the top of the tank, it lets the tank breathe so heat doesn't build up. But you did say you have leds and those don't produce much heat anyway.
 
The clownfish are only sting proof if they produce a healthy slime coat. The anemone could eat the clownfish if it ever chooses to do so. The corals stinging cells are different. They're meant to kill other corals that are too close, but in a stressed environment the cells will be released into the water column.


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
The clownfish are only sting proof if they produce a healthy slime coat. The anemone could eat the clownfish if it ever chooses to do so. The corals stinging cells are different. They're meant to kill other corals that are too close, but in a stressed environment the cells will be released into the water column.


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app

Well I'm doing a water change right now and I'll do them even more often to remove the sting cells
 
That won't stop other fish from jumping out. It's just common sense.

Maybe it's "traditional" not to have a hood - which means it's "traditional" for fish to jump out. Your choice. Fish jump out of covered tanks, even, so you should at the very least put in a little effort in keeping your beloved pets safe. That's all of our responsibility. Even a "lip" on the inside of the top would help, if not a full cover, along the edge. But, if you don't, you should expect your fish to jump out - all it takes is spooking them - could be a flickering light, a sudden movement, a door closing. Please do the responsible thing. It's the same as having a dog in an unenclosed yard, and having him get hit by a car.
Why risk it.
 
That won't stop other fish from jumping out. It's just common sense.

Maybe it's "traditional" not to have a hood - which means it's "traditional" for fish to jump out. Your choice. Fish jump out of covered tanks, even, so you should at the very least put in a little effort in keeping your beloved pets safe. That's all of our responsibility. Even a "lip" on the inside of the top would help, if not a full cover, along the edge. But, if you don't, you should expect your fish to jump out - all it takes is spooking them - could be a flickering light, a sudden movement, a door closing. Please do the responsible thing. It's the same as having a dog in an unenclosed yard, and having him get hit by a car.
Why risk it.

Good Question But the same as thousands and thousands of others, I prefer open tops, And in all the nearly 3 years of keeping clowns I've never experienced this, Didn't even hear of it. I believe fish can be kept whilst keeping the beauty of the tank but that's just my opinion, Yours is probably very different
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com