Alternatives to Pothos

duanes

MFK Moderators
Staff member
Moderator
MFK Member
Jun 7, 2007
21,028
26,361
2,910
Isla Taboga Panama via Milwaukee
I have used Pothos as a nitrate filtration aid, but it's not the only option.
One of my alternative favorites is Papyrus-Umbrella Palm (Cyperus alternifolis).
I have used it in Wisconsin in ponds, planted sumps, and directly in tanks, and use it here in Panama, where it is feral, I even place it in the yard where the washing machine sends waste water. It can tolerate wet, and dry conditions, the roots can be totally submerged, although the umbrellas need to be above the surface.
This is usually not a problem, because they grow 4 to 6 ft tall.
E42A928A-F635-47CC-BDC9-A6A15F14D4CD_1_201_a.jpeg
The tank above is 24"tall, and 6 ft long, the root ball loosely takes up about a foot of one end.
7E981F7D-D31D-41AE-99F2-E57318BC0E94_1_201_a.jpeg
It is one of the fastest growing plants, and reproduces easily.
The first one I bought in Wisconsin came from an auction of our aquarium club, for a buck or two (just a couple stems and small root system), It soon was in all planted sumps, in my pond, and in tanks.
To reproduce the root ball can be divided, or .......my favorite way is to bend a frond so the umbrella lhangs in the water....when it does, a new young plant begins to sprout.
D2140177-B7F8-4AE7-8914-DC7123CC1A25_1_201_a.jpeg
4891C1B5-97DE-412D-AAF6-ECACEE76CDAB_1_201_a.jpeg
Below, a shot of papyrus growing in pots in my pond in Milwaukee, being a tropical plant, it couldn't survive the winter there so it was brought in as a house plant.
1609952358090.png
.Below in a planted sump, and in a tank indoors.
1609952626351.png
1609958286325.png
Umbrella palm is originally a Malagasy plant (although it is found thrughout the world now, and grows wild (feral) here in Panama)) so I thought it was very apropos in my Paratilapia biotope tank.
1609958056929.png
 

KATALEKEEPER

Dovii
MFK Member
Nov 18, 2020
784
694
105
Brooklyn, Ny
I have used Pothos as a nitrate filtration aid, but it's not the only option.
One of my alternative favorites is Papyrus-Umbrella Palm (Cyperus alternifolis).
I have used it in Wisconsin in ponds, planted sumps, and directly in tanks, and use it here in Panama, where it is feral, I even place it in the yard where the washing machine sends waste water. It can tolerate wet, and dry conditions, the roots can be totally submerged, although the umbrellas need to be above the surface.
This is usually not a problem, because they grow 4 to 6 ft tall.
View attachment 1446203
The tank above is 24"tall, and 6 ft long, the root ball loosely takes up about a foot of one end.
View attachment 1446204
It is one of the fastest growing plants, and reproduces easily.
The first one I bought in Wisconsin came from an auction of our aquarium club, for a buck or two (just a couple stems and small root system), It soon was in all planted sumps, in my pond, and in tanks.
To reproduce the root ball can be divided, or .......my favorite way is to bend a frond so the umbrella lhangs in the water....when it does, a new young plant begins to sprout.
View attachment 1446205
View attachment 1446206
Below, a shot of papyrus growing in pots in my pond in Milwaukee, being a tropical plant, it couldn't survive the winter there so it was brought in as a house plant.
View attachment 1446207
.Below in a planted sump, and in a tank indoors.
View attachment 1446208
View attachment 1446211
Umbrella palm is originally a Malagasy plant (although it is found thrughout the world now, and grows wild (feral) here in Panama)) so I thought it was very apropos in my Paratilapia biotope tank.
View attachment 1446210
would papyrus work in an African cichlid setup? (tanganikyan)
 

duanes

MFK Moderators
Staff member
Moderator
MFK Member
Jun 7, 2007
21,028
26,361
2,910
Isla Taboga Panama via Milwaukee
It works in any tank with any fish that I've kept which include Africans, South and Central Americans, and Madagascans, any and all except those that would eat it, and the only fish I've had that eat it are, Cincelichthys bocourti, and pearsei.
 

esoxlucius

Balaclava Bot Butcher
MFK Member
Dec 30, 2015
3,689
13,738
194
UK
I use multiple varieties of pothos, tradescantia zebrina, tradescantia fluminensis, tradescantia pallida, and I'm going to be trying guynura aurantiaca or purple velvet.

View attachment 1446258
That is one if the best i've seen. Is it just fish you keep beneath that jungle or are there other animals lurking in there? I'd be scared to death of walking past the tank in case a jaguar leapt out and throttled me. Lol.

Joking aside, what level of nitrate do you have on water change day and what's your schedule like? I'd be looking for some serious results with such established greenery like that.

Note to mods:
We need a GOTM competition......Garden Of The Month!!!!
 

duanes

MFK Moderators
Staff member
Moderator
MFK Member
Jun 7, 2007
21,028
26,361
2,910
Isla Taboga Panama via Milwaukee
BTW, I didn't mean for this to be only about Papyrus, (the Title says "Alternatives" to Pothos.
Here is another alternative called Dieffenbachia, it is used all over the surface of a 180 gallon 6 ft tank.
0CFEB1CE-6316-413F-AC62-6AB81EFE8D2A_1_201_a.jpeg
Below, pulled one out of the tank, to help show its extensive root system.
49E01DD0-BD1D-413B-87C6-0D757BE5AD28_1_201_a.jpeg
The 180 gal tank was started about 3 years ago, and has never tested any measurable nitrate above the 5 ppm on an API test
AE0028E3-0F8F-4441-9307-F9D65924926B_1_201_a.jpeg

DDBA1162-0E43-4098-9BB9-A95DDCD45971_1_201_a.jpeg
 

Rass

Aimara
MFK Member
Oct 3, 2005
752
601
130
42
California
That is one if the best i've seen. Is it just fish you keep beneath that jungle or are there other animals lurking in there? I'd be scared to death of walking past the tank in case a jaguar leapt out and throttled me. Lol.

Joking aside, what level of nitrate do you have on water change day and what's your schedule like? I'd be looking for some serious results with such established greenery like that.

Note to mods:
We need a GOTM competition......Garden Of The Month!!!!
I have two tanks like this. Nitrates never even register with a standard water change routine. I used to do 50% a week, but over time I've cut it back to 30% every other week. The plants have been cut way back multiple times but always grow back. Also just fish in this one, all manner of cichlids have been grown out in here. The other tank is mutt guppies, shrimp, and snails. That tank is a constant zero for nitrates, and I go much longer in between water changes. Maybe 25% once a month.
 
zoomed.com
hikariusa.com
aqaimports.com
Store