another substrate thread

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Does anyone know if 3m t-grade sand is okay, I want a black sand and was told that this is not sharp and won't get sucked up when cleaning.

Thanks Kevin
 
I have always though pool sand is good for rays. Not so fine that it gets sucked into the python and doesnt irritate bellys.
 
I have been on the phone with numerous pool supply stores over the last two days and they told me that all pool filter sand, even though different brands, has the same make-up. It's 20 grade silica sand- all of it. 100% quartz doesn't mean its not made of silica because quartz is made of silica. So, if so many people on this forum use this sand with no problems, that's the route I'm going because its a really good price, I think it looks the best, and it apparently is ok for rays.
 
Works great for me so far. Bellys look fine. It sticks to them a little but that is expected. THey can shake it off when they want to.
 
do youself a fav and use a fine gravel like this

doesnt get sucked up by the python or filter doesnt stick to the rays easy to keep clean is 100% ray safe and it doesnt aftect the ph and it lime free and its real smooth

and best of all 2 members hear have bred their black rays on this gravel so the rays MUST like it

P1010478.JPG
 
keepinfish;1036069; said:
Works great for me so far. Bellys look fine. It sticks to them a little but that is expected. THey can shake it off when they want to.

:headbang2

so my pool filter sand is fine?
:D

finally i can get my rays
 
i agree with T1 fine gravel. all my literature is showing rays on fine gravel too. if you are spending a lot of money on you ray set up whats the extra expense to go with a fish safe substrate.
 
Well, I just love the look of sand. I have had aquariums with gravel my whole life. Stingrays are something different, and I want their aquarium to look different, too. If there was a sand that was a for sure bet, I'd go with that no question on the cost. But, since every sand I come across seems to have a possible negative effect, I will go with the one that most other people use and is the cheapest. I'm not saying anything is wrong with gravel; I have a show aquarium in my living room right now full of gravel, but I love the way a sand stingray tank looks.
 
id go with estes.......,, ive never had a problem with it and obviously people who have thousand dollar fish in estes sand mean they completely trust it with their rays...
 
another pic with a leo. I can post more pic tonight. I have a tank right now with the white estes in it. And I love it. go with the best. You will be happy!

100_0024.JPG
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com