Anyone else find africans boreing compared to Central/SA Cichlids?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
It's a vague question but in general, no, I don't find Africans boring in comparison to South/Central Americans. In fact I think the behavior of African cichlid is a bit more variable than the behaviors of SA/CA cichlids but I do very much enjoy both.
I'm still fascinated by the complex social structures of Malawi Mbuna. How their hierarchy works, who's where...it changes frequently. They're highly social animals. Most people don't bother to dig past the part where "they're pretty to look at" and mistake their constant activity for mindless movement. People knock them cause they're mouthbrooders and don't display any parental care but that's not the whole truth. A female mbuna can display very tender care and consideration for her fry. I've seen them take fry back into their mouths when they were already too big to fit more than a few in, hide their fry in small rock rubble because they're obviously safer there than in the pile of bigger rocks where bigger fish can fit through, even chew up and spit food for the little ones to eat. They can be very calculated and intentional.
The colony building behavior of other African cichlids is also quite fascinating, like those of Neolamprologus brichardi, and Neolamprologus pulcher. Two very similar cichlids, both colony-building only one species allows inactive males to stay within it's colony and the other chases away it's young males upon reaching sexual maturity. Both are rapid producers of fry and both make excellent parents and have the heart to challenge fish much larger than themselves to protect their colony.
So no, I find all groups of cichlids fascinating in their own way.
 
Sym;1153837; said:
CA/SA tend to recognize their owners more readily as well. Not just association to food with people, but distinct recognition of individuals."

Heck yeah....I'm a tall, bald guy, they see me 1/2 way across the house and know who I am
:D

Never kept African cichlids but have always been interested in the Frontosa, and the peacocks..they're beautiful fish
 
i have owned africans in the past and i think they have wonderful colours and and good to watch BUT then i got my X-Jag and now i think hes much better, so i think they are boring compared to americans.
 
I DO!!!!
 
Sym;1153761; said:
After keeping cichlids for years Im really starting to find the africans boreing. Sure there are some pretty ones but in general the american cichlids just seem to be more intelligent or maybe its that they have more personality. Not sure exactly what it is but I do find them much more interesting than africans. Anyone else?

I completely disagree with your observations, at least from my own experience of 20yrs keeping Africans. I started off with the SA's and I have to admit, I had a few firemouths that were true characters. I love the fish from Lake Victoria, the Obliquidens/Ruby Greens/Flamebacks and the Nyererei's. I guess the run of the mill Mbuna's might be lacking personality but those yellow labs seem to be a step above. I keep several Tropheus D's that are very playful with me, quite the pair of little hooligans if you ask me.

I love my fish, what can I say?
 
SA/CA all the way...however i've kept africans before and they are very theraputic just watching them shoal in a big mass of coulour!!! good for those who don't really appreciate fish when they come to your house.

CA/SA are more like PETS. my dovii has so much personality and you can play with him and rowl him up and he's still happy - just like a dog. he can definitely tell the difference between me and others when it comes to interaction
 
I keep both types. What I have observed is that both are personable. The SA/CA always want you to feed them and will watch you constantly and beg for food. Africans have thousands of years of instincts about protecting there little bit of area that many times they may seem to not acknowledge your presence outside of feeding time because they have to defend and stake out there small territory. it is those instincts that make them seem not personable like the SA/CA's. But I have hand fed my africans like I do my SA/CA cichlids. It did take more time since they are a bit more skittish.

I do agree the my SA/CAs spend more time watching me then the africans and appear more interactive to me, but I think that is mostly because the africans are like fish with ADHD and have to continually be do something.

I like both types and keep both. In their own tanks and some together. some people may frown upon this but I do use some of my africans as dithers for my big SA/CA's. they constantly move around fighting with each other paying little attention to the SA/CA's and add color and action.
 
its all about the africans, ive kept everything from firemouths to jaguars, and IMO africans are much more intelligent, active, colorful, not to mention their breeding/parenting behavior is very interesting, most sa's and ca's seem boreing and some even seem retarded to me, but thats just my opinion
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com