What I should've said was I believed those caribe to be tank bred and/or received from a hobbyist as ASO often sources piranha from within the trade or sometimes gets returns from customers that is restocked for sale. I assumed as much because their website does not list the caribe as wild caught (unless I overlooked it).I don’t believe anyone has bred Caribe. There may have been one report that may or may not have been confirmed. Those Caribe came in when they got shipments from Colombia and Peru. Red Bellies that they had are indeed tank bred.