aclockworkorange;4646781; said:Pinching pennies, losing dollars. A filter that won't last is just a waste of money in the long run. I would spend the $200 on the FX5 (first choice), or alternatively go with an eheim.
I actually own that exact same fake fx5, it works great. i had a minor defect with the lid, but i emailed the company which is in the united states and they sent me a new one, ever since then, not a single problem and its been running over a month.
OP, if you can't afford the fx5, then get the fake fx5. But i prefer sumps, so i would say the best filter would be a sump.