Can I keep a Bichir with a PBass

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
i wudnt do it... p bass eat very aggressively... meaning the polys wud not get much food unless you feed large amounts which will affect ur water quality... so if u got time for the water changes then go ahead..
 
Keeper of the Ropes;1388640; said:
Enchilada..... I like that just as much as I like the idea of PBass and *ha* Enchiladas in the same tank.... Enchilada! One of my Enchiladas is named Gustavo - Gustavo the Enchilada. :P Sounding quite Mexican instead of African, huh?

Keeper*

So, is this a suggestion not to keep Bichir with PBass?
 
mb_barton;1388786; said:
i wudnt do it... p bass eat very aggressively... meaning the polys wud not get much food unless you feed large amounts which will affect ur water quality... so if u got time for the water changes then go ahead..

I am in the process of setting up a 4GPH drip system so I should be getting about 100 gallons of dilution a day. As far as overfeeding, I feed my fish the largest food they can handle, so they usually get one or two portions then retire to digest it. I haven't had to feed fish for 2-3 minutes in a couple years.
 
tunerX;1390322; said:
So, is this a suggestion not to keep Bichir with PBass?

Sry lol I work @ Wendy's so sometimes I get carried away playing with Spanish sounding words. I was just saying that I would love to see a tank with both monster species in it - but I'd have to say that you need to make sure the Endlis are the same size if not bigger. I wouldn't try it with any other species - except maybe a congicus - because I personally don't think any of the other species are tough enough to take all the activity around them and tough enough to stake a claim on their food. But that's just me :) Good luck with whatever you decide!

Keeper*
 
Congicus gets bigger, but no it doesn't matter so much :D
 
you can't go with the max recorded size. P. endlicheri endlicheri will most likely reach a realistic max size of under 24" in the aquarium, although supposedly they can reach close to 30" in the wild. P. endlicheri congicus has a larger max recorded size. in the aquarium, i'd say realistically under 30".

this will take a good number of years, so don't expect this in like two years or something. and it'll also depend on other factors whether a particular bichir would ever get that big (e.g. some bichirs are naturally more greedy eater than others, and obviously they'd have the best growth).

having said that, i think either would be fine as long as sizes are compatible. and make sure the bichir gets enough to eat.
 
Thanks everyone.

Now I just need to find someone with a larger endlicheri endlicheri or endlicheri congicus.

I have an email out to rehoboth aquatics. He said he doesn't have congicus, but does have endlicheri. I am just waiting on a reply about the size of the endlicheri. If things don't look kosher between the PBass and the poly, as the PBass get bigger, then I will move the poly to another tank for further growing.

Thanks again.
 
many of the lower jaws can get real big.
ive had an endli grow 2 inches per month til he hit about 6 inches!
im growing out a pbass to try this.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com