Can I pit these fish in a 29 gallon aquarium?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
i wouldnt quarantaine if i were you. I mean the fish arent so expensive, and if you get most at the same shop at the same time. They probably either are all sick or they aren't since most smaller shops use 1 water circuit system for the tanks.
If they get sick you can treat them all at the same time.

corydoras need sand. So with that gravel i would not recommend corydoras

i dont get why you would introduce group fish a few at the time?
Just get the whole squad in 1 go. your risk of getting sick fish only gets higher when you get them a few at a time. Also they are group fish so its better for them to be in a group from the start. That way they wont be so skitisch.
 
I only have 1 tank and non expensive fish so I don't quarantine. Now if you have a long established tank or expensive fish and you're getting something new, you want to quarantine to make sure your new fish isn't bringing parasites or disease into your existing community, or expensive or delicate fish you may have. When you say cycling do you mean fishless cycling with ammonia and testing the water? or just that it's running?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Brickosaurus
i wouldnt quarantaine if i were you. I mean the fish arent so expensive, and if you get most at the same shop at the same time. They probably either are all sick or they aren't since most smaller shops use 1 water circuit system for the tanks.
If they get sick you can treat them all at the same time.

corydoras need sand. So with that gravel i would not recommend corydoras

i dont get why you would introduce group fish a few at the time?
Just get the whole squad in 1 go. your risk of getting sick fish only gets higher when you get them a few at a time. Also they are group fish so its better for them to be in a group from the start. That way they wont be so skitisch.

Thanks for the tip about the Cory's! Is there any other bottom feeders I could do? If so how many?

So I'll probably just go ahead and introduce the fish one school at a time. I don't think I'll be able to get all at once. I'll probably be buying all of my fish from the same Petsmart, because my local Petco sucks
 
A brand new tank, being stocked with its first inhabitants? I might be persuaded to bypass quarantine; otherwise, quarantine is a must, IMHO. Adding new fish to an established tank without quarantine is like unprotected sex; you might be okay...but you might not...and if you continue to do it you will eventually lose the coin toss. The cost of the fish is a non-issue; if you have a tank full of inexpensive fish which you have maintained and grown up for months or years...and you then lose them to an unknown pathogen introduced with unquarantined new fish...are you really going to say "Oh, well, they were cheap!" Once you invested time and effort into your fish, there is more than money involved...never mind the ethical considerations.

How do you set up a quarantine tank? You use a filter to keep the water clean, a heater to maintain the correct temperature, some decor to provide the fish some sense of security, and you monitor your water conditions/parameter to determine if/when the tank is cycled. In other words...you set up a quarantine tank just like any other tank. Once you have established tanks you can keep extra sponge filters in them, which can then be placed into a new quarantine tank to create an "instantly-cycled" tank when needed.

I don't have any experience with bottled bacteria so can't say how well they work, but once your tank is cycled, each time you add fish you are adding to the bioload and thus demanding the bacteria to reproduce and grow their numbers to deal with the additional waste. If I add ten fish to an established cycled aquarium that already contains 50 other fish roughly that size, I have increased the bioload by 20%; the bacterial population will grow quickly and "catch up" to the new, higher bioload within probably a day or two, no harm done. But if I add ten fish to a tank that only contains one fish up to that point, then I have increased the bioload 1000%; the bacteria will take longer to reproduce to the required level, and there will be spikes in ammonia and likely nitrite for several days. This is the main reason for not adding large quantities of fish at the same time.

This should go without saying, but I'll say it anyways: you should have a liquid test kit like the API, and use it to monitor your water parameters to determine when/if you are fully cycled, and how your tank reacts after an addition of livestock.

Finally, try to bear in mind that not all fish are ideally suited to identical conditions. You want Neons, Zebras and Platies, all of which would be happy in the low 70F range...you don't specify which species of Corydoras you like, so that's an unknown...but you also want a Dwarf or Honey Gourami which, in my experience, is much more suited to 80F than to 70F. Compromise at 75F? That will likely work, but...some of the fish will be closer to their maximum, while others will be at their minimum...which means that literally none of them are in their ideal zone. Personally, I would get Cardinals instead of Neons...at least as nice, and better suited to higher temps. Skip the Zebras, and do a bit of reading to see which species of Corydoras will be best suited to the upper 70's...there are many...and then keep your tank around 78-80F.

Or...get the Zebras and Neons and Platies, pick a cooler-water Corydoras like perhaps paleatus, skip the Gourami and set your thermostat to 72F. The point is simply to decide what you like best, and then cater to those species rather than forcing fish together who don't really belong together.
 
A brand new tank, being stocked with its first inhabitants? I might be persuaded to bypass quarantine; otherwise, quarantine is a must, IMHO. Adding new fish to an established tank without quarantine is like unprotected sex; you might be okay...but you might not...and if you continue to do it you will eventually lose the coin toss. The cost of the fish is a non-issue; if you have a tank full of inexpensive fish which you have maintained and grown up for months or years...and you then lose them to an unknown pathogen introduced with unquarantined new fish...are you really going to say "Oh, well, they were cheap!" Once you invested time and effort into your fish, there is more than money involved...never mind the ethical considerations.

How do you set up a quarantine tank? You use a filter to keep the water clean, a heater to maintain the correct temperature, some decor to provide the fish some sense of security, and you monitor your water conditions/parameter to determine if/when the tank is cycled. In other words...you set up a quarantine tank just like any other tank. Once you have established tanks you can keep extra sponge filters in them, which can then be placed into a new quarantine tank to create an "instantly-cycled" tank when needed.

I don't have any experience with bottled bacteria so can't say how well they work, but once your tank is cycled, each time you add fish you are adding to the bioload and thus demanding the bacteria to reproduce and grow their numbers to deal with the additional waste. If I add ten fish to an established cycled aquarium that already contains 50 other fish roughly that size, I have increased the bioload by 20%; the bacterial population will grow quickly and "catch up" to the new, higher bioload within probably a day or two, no harm done. But if I add ten fish to a tank that only contains one fish up to that point, then I have increased the bioload 1000%; the bacteria will take longer to reproduce to the required level, and there will be spikes in ammonia and likely nitrite for several days. This is the main reason for not adding large quantities of fish at the same time.

This should go without saying, but I'll say it anyways: you should have a liquid test kit like the API, and use it to monitor your water parameters to determine when/if you are fully cycled, and how your tank reacts after an addition of livestock.

Finally, try to bear in mind that not all fish are ideally suited to identical conditions. You want Neons, Zebras and Platies, all of which would be happy in the low 70F range...you don't specify which species of Corydoras you like, so that's an unknown...but you also want a Dwarf or Honey Gourami which, in my experience, is much more suited to 80F than to 70F. Compromise at 75F? That will likely work, but...some of the fish will be closer to their maximum, while others will be at their minimum...which means that literally none of them are in their ideal zone. Personally, I would get Cardinals instead of Neons...at least as nice, and better suited to higher temps. Skip the Zebras, and do a bit of reading to see which species of Corydoras will be best suited to the upper 70's...there are many...and then keep your tank around 78-80F.

Or...get the Zebras and Neons and Platies, pick a cooler-water Corydoras like perhaps paleatus, skip the Gourami and set your thermostat to 72F. The point is simply to decide what you like best, and then cater to those species rather than forcing fish together who don't really belong together.

So I'm going to have to spend $50+ to set up and cycle an extra 10g aquarium. (That I also have to find a space for) just to be able to add fish to my tank?

I'm not rich, so I don't have a bunch of sponge filters lying around. (I've never even used sponge filters before)

I've ordered my test kit. And am currently waiting for it to arrive, and am still going to add the fish a few at a time.
 
So I'm going to have to spend $50+ to set up and cycle an extra 10g aquarium. (That I also have to find a space for) just to be able to add fish to my tank?

I'm not rich, so I don't have a bunch of sponge filters lying around. (I've never even used sponge filters before)

I've ordered my test kit. And am currently waiting for it to arrive, and am still going to add the fish a few at a time.

You don't "have to" do anything you don't want to do. You asked about quarantine hows and whys, I provided an answer based upon my own experiences and...as I stated...my own opinions. Someone will likely come along any second with an opinion you will find more palatable.

You already have the 10-gallon tank; I bet you could find a small air pump and sponge for $15, maybe less online.
 
You don't "have to" do anything you don't want to do. You asked about quarantine hows and whys, I provided an answer based upon my own experiences and...as I stated...my own opinions. Someone will likely come along any second with an opinion you will find more palatable.

You already have the 10-gallon tank; I bet you could find a small air pump and sponge for $15, maybe less online.

Thanks for the info! I'll probably set up the quarantine tank. But it most likely won't be right away.
 
They would probably fare better if you sticked with more of the same species rather than a few of each specie. 10-12 danios or neons with 8-10 cories would be better imo



 
  • Like
Reactions: Brickosaurus
They would probably fare better if you sticked with more of the same species rather than a few of each specie. 10-12 danios or neons with 8-10 cories would be better imo




Well I'm probably not going to Cory's since they do better with a sand bottom. And I currently have gravel. I'm already changing the number of neons to 8

And I may just skip the danios for an extra honey gourami. I'm not %100 sure yet. So any suggestions are welcome
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com