filter

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
For a clean tank, and cycled tank, one bio filter, and one mech filter would be recommended. I personally would recommend the use of an Eheim 2217, 2028, 2076, 2078 for bio, and an AC110 for mech filtration, running ehfimech and efhisubstrat pro in the eheim, and 2 foam blocks, and 1 biomax in the ac110.
 
EHEIM EHEIM EHEIM oh and EHEIM lol. I say go for a 2028 or a 2217 if you want to go cheaper. The Multi-stage c-360 from Marineland is pretty good as well my dad just ordered one from drsfostersmith.com with a wet/dry because his 2215 just went after 15 years of running. We don't know what happened it just made a clicking noise then stopped and would start back up. The 2215 is a very good canister as well and strongly recommend it.
 
fish boy in toronto;1031904; said:
so ehime is better than fluval

It just doesn't compare. Eheim is superb in all filtration can't get much better than them unless you build a top quality canister better. Fluvals are good but not great. On a scale 1 to 10 fluvals rank 6-7 Eheim 8 to 9.5. No filter can attain a 10 though because every filter is flawless.
 
on my 150 I have 2 Emp 400's and a Fluval FX5 I personally dont like eheims because I have had a few bad experiences and to me they are overly priced...
 
Cross127;1031926; said:
It just doesn't compare. Eheim is superb in all filtration can't get much better than them unless you build a top quality canister better. Fluvals are good but not great. On a scale 1 to 10 fluvals rank 6-7 Eheim 8 to 9.5. No filter can attain a 10 though because every filter is flawless.

That is a very generic thing to say. Eheim filters can range from fairly bad to very good. As do fluvals. Eheims in general are a well built filter, and their media is hard pressed to be passed.
 
fish boy in toronto;1031952;1031952 said:
so would the fx 5 be good enough
FX5 are good filters, but they have too much foam IMO, but that makes them great in terms of a mech filter. Again, it is a bad idea to run a tank on only one filter. Which is why I recommended what I did originally.
 
As much as I like the FX5 you shouldn't run your tank with just it alone. If you want to use the FX5 then add a good HOB bio-filter like the Emporer 400's If you want to use an eheim canister (better bio-filtration) then use a pair of AC110 for extra mechanical filtration. Either way you go you should run a couple of Hydro5 sponge filters for safety.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com