Getting another tank. Need ideas, input.

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Stump

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Nov 19, 2008
2,963
3
0
36
Bichir Alley
I'll be picking up a 40 gallon breeder tomorrow. I was thinking about a 55 gallon, but because of my concern of the weight on my floor, and the fact that a 40 breeder has more turning space, I decided against it.

After the tank has finished cycling I will be moving my 5" Black Ghost Knife into it (perhaps maybe my catfish - though I know if I move him he will be PISSED). He is currently in my 29 gallon along with my Angel, 3 SDs, Striped Peacock, tiny Clown Pleco, and P. Blochii. Despite it being a bit overstocked, all are happy, and have more than enough room to swim around. They've been going strong for months. I think it's the way I have it set up -- little tank, with a lot of open space, two pvc corners under flat slate, a nice fake tree stump, and a small garden area. Anyway, I was hoping to put a cichlid or two into the 40 gallon along with my BGK (if I do, my cat won't go in there). I need a cichlid that tolerates 6.0 ph, and will be passive-aggressive towards my BGK. In other words, one that will NOT attack the Knife, but will defend itself easily if it gets attacked. I am not interested AT ALL in dwarf cichlids. They're too... uh... not cichlid-y. :screwy:

If anyone has kept a BGK successfully with a relatively small cichlid that doesn't get over 7-8", i'd love to hear about it. If not, I am still open to all ideas, and would love to hear all input.



****disclaimer****

Talk about getting a bigger tank (ie 'bigger is better'; 'the fish will be happier in _________' etc.) will be ignored completely.



Thanks.
 
Also I should add that I usually am not too fond of long-bodied cichlids, unless they are full-out Pikes... Again, thanks.
 
Nicarguenses? Although longish, beautiful! Not sure but maybe a EBJD?
 
woofy;2553494; said:
like festivums? severums, acaras, ect.
I really like Severums. Acaras are a close second.

Would a severum do well with my knife?
 
orbit;2553502; said:
Nicarguenses? Although longish, beautiful! Not sure but maybe a EBJD?
Do you really think I could get away with an electric blue Jack? I didn't consider that... I like their look too.









Thanks for the ideas so far guys.:)
 
nolapete;2553524; said:
You should get either a (36x18x21) 58 or (36x18x24) 67. They are the same footprint of the 40 Breeder and not that much more in cost.
Again, the weight of each concerns me. I live in an older house. The joists are 2x8's spaced at 16" on-center, but still... I don't want to risk anything.
 
go discus!
maybe severums.
 
Stump;2553522; said:
Do you really think I could get away with an electric blue Jack? I didn't consider that... I like their look too.


Thanks for the ideas so far guys.:)

If im not mistaken, captive bred JD's usually don't exceed 9" total size. And they aren't the aggressors if by them selve's. Singular only.

Start with a small Juvi. Should be ok. Hopefully someone with a EBJD will chime in and give the full on it.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com