Green Terror .vs. Oscar

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Green Terror .vs. Oscar

  • Green Terror ( Male )

    Votes: 99 55.3%
  • Tiger Oscar

    Votes: 80 44.7%

  • Total voters
    179
McFall;4223306; said:
55 gallon

Well that changes things. You could probably keep a GT in the 55 for life, the oscar would be fine for a year... keep in mind 55 is 12'' wide internally, oscars can grow up to 15'' over several years.
 
McFall;4223306; said:
55 gallon
Oh, I wish you would have said that in the first place. An oscar isn't even an option for your tank size.


BlackShark11k;4223314; said:
Well that changes things. You could probably keep a GT in the 55 for life, the oscar would be fine for a year... keep in mind 55 is 12'' wide internally, oscars can grow up to 15'' over several years.
I agree, and GT's are capable of reaching 12" if I'm not mistaken, so there's a possibility that even the GT wouldn't work out.
 
I have an oscar, but no experience w/ GTs. If I had the choice again, then I would get a GT. They just have more color and don't get as big and messy.
 
I mean i have a 125 with some dempseys and polyps and a convict, just didnt know if i could put the GT in there as well
 
All this for a 55g? Yeah, Green Terror is the right choice for that tank for while. He'll likely outgrow it in a few years. But by then you'll have bought a bigger tank, been given a free Oscar, and realize how dumb the GT is so you'll be moving him on anyway.

I mean i have a 125 with some dempseys and polyps and a convict, just didnt know if i could put the GT in there as well
Oh, that's different. Yes, you have room for either one in there.
 
McFall;4223129; said:
im favoring the green terror big time, is there any way to get it to come ot the top to eat the floating pellets?


Don't let these guys fool you. GT's are very personable fish.

My male is about 5" and will eat out of my hand. I'll try to make a video of it if you want.



McFall;4223427; said:
alrighty, think im gonna go with the GT :D

:clap:clap:clap:clap:clap:clap:clap
 
Just a male and female with about 30 babies and a couple of little catfish in a 156 gallon. I've already fed them just a litle while ago but the male might take some more, he's a pig.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com